Exhibit C

STANDARD LETTER TO REFEREES WHO WERE SENT
THE SCHOOL OR DEPARTMENTAL SEARCH LETTER

Date

CONFIDENTIAL

Name
Address

Dear ____________:

     On [date], [I/the Chair of the Department of X/the Dean of the School of X] wrote to ask for your help in an evaluation [we/the Department/the School] [was/were] conducting in connection with the possible nomination of [Dr./Professor] [Candidate] to tenure. Your response to [our/his/her] request was greatly appreciated. [We/The Department/The School] [has/have] decided to nominate [Dr./Professor] [Candidate], and we are now preparing for the review that our Provost will conduct with the assistance of a special, University-wide ad hoc committee.

     I am writing to ask if you would like to add to the comments on [Dr./Professor] [Candidate]'s qualifications in your previous letter, a copy of which is enclosed. In particular, we would appreciate your views on how [he/she] compares with other scholars currently in the field of X, such as those on the enclosed list, and whether [he/she] is likely to be among the leaders in that field in the future. The list that we have provided is meant only as a guide. Please feel free to adjust it as you see fit. Not everyone on the list is at the same age and level of experience, and this, of course, needs to considered in comparing them.

     I realize that my request imposes an added burden on your time. However, the opinions of outside referees play an important part in Columbia's process of tenure review. Therefore, we would be grateful for any additional information that you think we might find helpful in conducting [Dr./Professor] [Candidate]'s review. We will hold your response in confidence to the extent permitted by law and show it only to the Provost, members of the ad hoc committee, and the [Departmental Chair/Executive Committee of the Department/School] [and the Committee(s) on Appointments and Promotions of the Faculty of Dental Medicine/Medicine/Public Health and of the Faculty of Health Sciences].

     With thanks in advance,

Sincerely,

[Dean/Vice President]

Enclosures: Curriculum Vitae
  Previous Letter of Evaluation