What should have been the definitive
experiment
Griffith’s experiments further defined the gene but brought us no
closer to understanding the composition of genes.  Then in the 1940s a
group of scientists at Rockefeller University carried out a study to
finally identify the genetic material.  Again working with
Dipplococcus pneumonia, these investigators, Avery, McCarthy, and
MacLeod first showed that they could convert non infectious rough (R)
pneumococcus into smooth (S) virulent pneumococcus by mixing heat
killed (S) with live (R) and plating them onto plates got smooth
bacteria.  This became their assay.  Next they isolated the material in
(S) that transformed (R).  They began with (S) bacteria and isolated
DNA by alcohol precipitating and then spooling it out.  This material
was able to transform (R).  This material was exhaustively extracted to
remove any protein.  And again it transformed.  Next they treated this
material with RNAse, no effect, protease, no effect and finally DNAse.
The DNAse killed the transforming activity and so they concluded that
DNA was the genetic material.  This was not widely accepted.