Kermit Security Reference Authors: Jeffrey Altman, Frank da Cruz [1]The Kermit Project, [2]Columbia University Applies to: [3]C-Kermit 8.0.200, 12 Dec 2001 [4]Kermit 95 2.00 (not available yet). [5]An earlier version of this document covers [6]C-Kermit 7.0 and [7]K95 1.1.17-20. Abstract: Security methods explained: Kerberos, SSL/TLS, SRP, SSH. How to configure and use them with C-Kermit and Kermit 95. This page last updated: 12 December 2001 [ [8]Kermit Home ] [ [9]C-Kermit ] [ [10]Kermit 95 ] ________________________________________________________________________ CONTENTS 1. [11]INTRODUCTION 2. [12]DISCLAIMERS 3. [13]KERMIT SECURITY USER GUIDE 4. [14]INSTALLATION AND CONFIGURATION I. [15]WHERE TO FIND SECURE TELNET AND FTP SERVERS II. [16]MULTIHOMED HOSTS, FIREWALLS, NATS III. [17]INTRODUCTION TO CERTIFICATES [18]GLOSSARY [19]REFERENCES [20]TRADEMARKS ________________________________________________________________________ 1. INTRODUCTION [ [21]Top ] [ [22]Contents ] [ [23]Glossary ] [ [24]Next ] CHAPTER CONTENTS 1.1. [25]Secure Connections 1.2. [26]Internet Protocols 1.3. [27]Authentication 1.4. [28]Encryption 1.5. [29]Integrity SECURITY is the hot topic on the Internet. Security systems and protocols abound. But it was not always so. In the early days, the mere act of putting two computers in touch with each other was quite amazing. To connect multiple diverse computers to a common network, allowing any pair of them to communicate, was almost inconceivable. When the [30]ARPANET (precursor of the Internet) was first operational on October 1, 1969, the eager task for many years afterwards was to open up more and more sites to it. The architecture of the network and its protocols were developed in research laboratories in an atmosphere of trust. Only later, when the ARPANET became the world-wide Internet and was opened up to limitless numbers of people, did security become an issue: hackers, crackers, script kiddies, terrorists, spies, swindlers, saboteurs, blackmailers, pranksters, and pests of every sort inundate the network and every computer on it with a constant barrage of probes and attacks. It is increasingly necessary to secure connections from eavesdropping and malicious tampering (not to mention spam, worms, viruses, and denial-of-service attacks, but that's [31]another story). The network itself is not secure. By its very nature and fundamental design, it is entirely open[32]*. While it might be possible to insert security at the transport and/or network layers, transparent to all applications, the approach until now has been to layer security protocols over TCP and IP: some of them standard, some not so standard. Even among the standard ones, there are many to choose from. This approach requires one or more security methods to be programmed into each and every client and server application that is to make or accept secure Internet connections. The situation should improve in the future as security becomes part of the network itself through evolving standards such as [33]IPSec, [34]IPv6, and [35]DNSSEC. Meanwhile, insecure connections remain the norm, in which passwords, credit-card information, private correspondence, and so on can be captured and/or altered in transit by malicious persons. Security remains elusive because we have a 30+ year history of open networks, clients, and servers, and because of the many competing security methods, the shifting definitions of each one, various legal entanglements, and the overall complexity of the entire topic. Why should I care about security? The reasons are obvious: to prevent fraud on your person, theft of your money or identity, hijacking of your computer accounts, tampering with your research results; any number of malicious acts aimed at you or performed by someone masquerading as you. Perhaps an even more compelling reason to care is that more and more sites are requiring secure clients for access: plain old dialup or insecure Telnet or FTP simply can't be used any more. Kermit software has offered secure connections since 1998. This document presents the security methods embodied in [36]C-Kermit 8.0 and [37]Kermit 95 2.00, which include: * Kerberos([38]TM) IV and V * Secure Remote Password([39]TM)(SRP) * Secure Sockets Layer(SSL)/Transport Layer Security(TLS) * Secure Shell ([40]TM) (SSH) ([41]TM) v1 and v2 (built into K95, external in C-Kermit) * Microsoft NT LAN Manager (NTLM, K95 only) * This is a slight exaggeration; a ever-increasing amount of filtering occurs in routers; local networks are increasingly switched rather than broadcast, etc. ________________________________________________________________________ 1.1. Secure Connections [ [42]Top ] [ [43]Contents ] [ [44]Chapter Contents ] [ [45]Glossary ] What is a secure connection? A connection is secure if it provides: * Authentication of the user to the host/service without the transmission of the user's password; * Authentication of the host to the user; * Privacy, through a shared secret that can be used as an end-to-end encryption key; and: * Integrity: the assurance that the data has not been altered in transit. A secure connection requires two applications, one on each end, that support (and can negotiate) a common security method; for example, a Telnet client on your desktop and a Telnet server at the remote site, both equipped with Kerberos V protocols. Kermit software supports a variety of connection methods, including serial ports, modems, and TCP/IP. Presently, secure connections are supported only over TCP/IP connections. Since there are several security methods to consider (Kerberos, SSL, ...) and several TCP/IP application protocols where they can be used (Telnet, FTP, HTTP, ...), and different platforms for the clients and servers (Unix, VMS, Windows, OS/2, ...), the possibilities are many. To complicate matters, every Kermit program can come with or without security. Non-secure versions are required by USA export law. Secure versions can be built with any combination of the security methods listed above: Kerberos IV but not Kerberos V, SRP and SSL/TLS but not Kerberos, etc. Kermit 95 has either no security methods built in or else all of them. C-Kermit on Unix can have any combination, depending on the libraries available on each platform and which ones were selected by the builder. ________________________________________________________________________ 1.2. Internet Protocols [ [46]Top ] [ [47]Contents ] [ [48]Chapter Contents ] [ [49]Glossary ] Let's begin by looking at the Internet protocols that Kermit supports to see which security options are available for each: TELNET (Network Virtual Terminal Protocol) The Telnet protocol can be used to establish the most secure connections with the greatest choice of authentication and privacy method. Kermit's Telnet implementation supports Kerberos 4, Kerberos 5, Secure Remote Password (SRP), NTLM (K95 only), and [50]X.509 certificates for client and server authentication. Privacy can be accomplished with the Secure Sockets Layer (SSL) or Transport Layer Security (TLS) cipher suites, or DES, CAST, or 3DES streaming ciphers. FTP (File Transfer Protocol) An FTP client can make secure connections for both the command and data channels as described in Internet [51]RFC 2228. Kermit's FTP implementation supports Kerberos 4, GSSAPI Kerberos 5, SRP, and SSL/TLS. HTTP (Hyper Text Transfer Protocol) HTTP can be used with SSL or TLS to submit requests and receive responses in a secure manner as described in [52]RFC 2818. RLOGIN (Remote Login) The Remote Login protocol can be used with Kerberos 4 or 5 to make authenticated connections. After authentication the DES streaming cipher can be used for privacy. SSL (Secure Socket Layer) / TLS (Transport Layer Security The SSL and TLS protocols can be used by themselves to establish a private connection to a host. Authentication of the server (and perhaps the client) is performed via exchange and verification of [53]X.509 certificates or Kerberos 5 credentials. Kermit also can make Telnet connections over a secure SSL or TLS tunnel. Kerberos 5 User-to-User The Kerberos 5 user-to-user protocol can make authenticated and private connections between two end-user operated copies of Kermit. The table below summarizes which security methods Kermit can support for each Internet service if those security methods are built in to Kermit. If your copy of Kermit supports a particular security method for a particular service, you can use it if the server supports the same method. You see out which security methods your Kermit program supports by giving it the SHOW FEATURES command. _________________________________________________________________ Protocol Krb4 Krb5 SSL/TLS SRP SSH NTLM Telnet Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes K95 Rlogin Yes Yes No No No No SSL/TLS No Yes Yes No No No K5 User-User No Yes No No No No FTP Yes Yes Yes Yes No No HTTP No No Yes No No No Kermit Yes Yes Yes Yes No K95 SSH No ?? No ?? Yes No ________________________________________________________________________ 1.3. Authentication [ [54]Top ] [ [55]Contents ] [ [56]Chapter Contents ] [ [57]Glossary ] SECTION CONTENTS 1.3.1. [58]Kerberos 1.3.2. [59]SRP 1.3.3. [60]NTLM 1.3.4. [61]X.509 Certificates AUTHENTICATION is the means by which one party proves its identity to to another. The most common authentication method is the familiar process of logging in with a username and password. When you do this on an insecure network connection, your identity and password are transmitted in clear text and can be "sniffed" by anybody who has access to any of the components of the network path; for example, by anybody who has a PC on a (non-switched) Ethernet network over which your information passes. Furthermore, when you make (say) a Telnet connection to a network, you accept the fact the you must authenticate yourself to it, but how do you know that the host itself is genuine? In the normal course of events, there is no requirement that it authenticate itself to you. Enter secure authentication. Any secure authentication scheme requires central management of identities, as in the Kerberos authentication system ([62]Section 1.3.1), X.509 certificates ([63]Appendix III), or Secure Remote Password ([64]Section 1.3.2). This type of security is best suited for large organizations -- universities, government agencies, corporations, hospitals -- that have a full-time professional network / security administration staff. The learning curve and startup time are significant, but worth the effort. Any security method can be breached, so the true measure of its effectiveness is its manageability: can breaches be repaired, can compromised identities be reclaimed? It is for these reasons that Microsoft, Sun, Apple, HP, IBM, and many Linux or BSD vendors are increasingly distributing Kerberos 5 as a core part of their operating systems. Unfortunately, the startup costs of a secure authentication system are sometimes so daunting that some organizations simply don't bother, and instead let users fend for themselves with unsigned public/private key pair schemes, such as SSH public key authentication and PGP. The only administrative tasks required up front are the installation and/or distribution of the required client and server software. This is not a secure authentication system; quite the opposite: it bypasses any secure authentication / authorization system that might be in place. And keys, once compromised, can not be revoked by those responsible for the security of the host: a serious consideration since so many security keys are stored on insecure disks (e.g. in Windows 9x/ME) ripe for picking. 1.3.1. Kerberos [ [65]Top ] [ [66]Contents ] [ [67]Chapter Contents ] [ [68]Section Contents ] [ [69]Glossary ] Kerberos is a method, developed at Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), by which two parties communicating over a TCP/IP connection can authenticate each other through a trusted, centrally managed third party without sending passwords across the network. The Kerberos protocols are defined in Internet RFCs [70]1510, [71]1964, and others. You can read more about Kerberos at the following websites: * [72]http://web.mit.edu/kerberos/www/ * [73]http://nii.isi.edu/info/kerberos/ * [74]http://nii.isi.edu/publications/kerberos-neuman-tso.html There are, in fact, two Kerberos protocols: Kerberos IV (4) and Kerberos V (5), the latter being the more flexible and secure protocol. The two are totally separate and incompatible. Any given site might support neither, either one, or both. One of the unique benefits associated with the use of Kerberos 5 authentication is its Single Sign-On (SSO) capability. This allows a user to enter their password once on the local machine, establish a secure connection to a second machine and from there establish additional connections without requiring the user to enter their password a second time. When both the client and server support the same version of Kerberos (4 or 5), Kerberos authentication with or without encryption can be negotiated. A "Kerberized" version of Kermit can make a connection to a non-Kerberized host, and a non-Kerberized host can accept a connection from a Kerberized version of Kermit, as long as neither side is configured to require Kerberos authentication. Kerberos authentication has been integrated into Telnet, Rlogin, FTP, and SSL/TLS as well as many other protocols not supported by Kermit. As part of the authentication process a session key is shared by the client and server that can be used to encrypt the current session. 1.3.2. SRP [ [75]Top ] [ [76]Contents ] [ [77]Chapter Contents ] [ [78]Section Contents ] [ [79]Glossary ] Stanford University's Secure Remote Password (SRP) protocol is a method by which two parties can mutually authenticate each other in a secure manner through a Zero Knowledge Identification system. SRP is defined in Internet [80]RFC 2945. You can read more about SRP at the following website: [81]http://www-cs-students.stanford.edu/~tjw/srp/ SRP authentication has been integrated into the Telnet and FTP protocol definitions (if not yet into all Telnet and FTP clients and servers). As a result of the authentication, a shared secret is produced that can be used to encrypt the authenticated session. 1.3.3. NTLM [ [82]Top ] [ [83]Contents ] [ [84]Chapter Contents ] [ [85]Section Contents ] [ [86]Glossary ] Microsoft NT Lan Manager (NTLM) authentication is implemented in Kermit 95 only. Its only use is to authenticate Kermit 95 to Microsoft Windows based Telnet services distributed as part of Windows 2000, Windows XP Professional, and the NT Services for Unix products. Kermit 95 can also use NTLM to authenticate incoming Telnet sessions when it is running under Windows NT/2000/XP. When running under Windows 95/98/98SE/ME, Kermit 95 can only be an authenticating client. NTLM does not negotiate a shared secret and cannot be used to establish encrypted sessions. Therefore, connections made with NTLM are not considered secure although it is definitely better to use NTLM authentication than it is to transmit a password in clear text. NTLM is a proprietary protocol considered to be a trade secret by Microsoft. When establishing connections with another Kermit 95 configured to accept incoming connections, Kermit 95 can negotiate NTLM over a SSL/TLS session. Security is then provided by SSL/TLS while authentication is performed with NTLM. 1.3.4. X.509 Certificates [ [87]Top ] [ [88]Contents ] [ [89]Chapter Contents ] [ [90]Section Contents ] [ [91]Glossary ] When SSL/TLS is used to provide security, authentication of the server and optionally the client can be performed using [92]X.509 Public Key Certificates. Certificates are used to exchange a public key for use in establishing an encrypted connection and can be verified against a known trusted Root Certificate and a Certificate Revocation List (CRL) to indicate its authenticity and validity. The contents of the certificate can then be used to determine the identity of the remote service or the client. C-Kermit and Kermit 95 provide mechanisms for the customization of the certificate to userid mapping. ________________________________________________________________________ 1.4. Encryption [ [93]Top ] [ [94]Contents ] [ [95]Chapter Contents ] [ [96]Glossary ] Export of software incorporating strong encryption is [97]regulated by United States law. SECTION CONTENTS 1.4.1. [98]Telnet 1.4.2. [99]FTP 1.4.3. [100]SSL/TLS 1.4.4. [101]SSH 1.4.5. [102]HTTP 1.4.6. [103]Rlogin ENCRYPTION is the process by which data is encoded to prevent anybody from deciphering it except those for whom it is intended. Encryption is an essential component of Internet security because of the Internet's open architecture; since (in principal) everybody can watch your sessions, you have to scramble them to keep them private. A variety of encryption methods, or algorithms, exists ranging from easy to crack to next-to-impossible (but not truly impossible: if the data can be decrypted legitimately, it can also be decrypted illegitimately given adequate resources). Most modern encryption/decryption algorithms use keys as part of the process, either provided by the user or obtained automatically from a shared secret. For any given algorithm, the longer the key the more secure the encryption. Each application protocol such as Telnet, FTP and HTTP defines its own set of protocols for encrypting a session based on the authentication method. 1.4.1. Telnet Encryption [ [104]Top ] [ [105]Contents ] [ [106]Chapter Contents ] [ [107]Section Contents ] [ [108]Glossary ] The following encryption algorithms can be negotiated for a Telnet session with the Telnet Encryption Option ([109]RFC 2946) when used with Kerberos IV, Kerberos V, or Secure Remote Password authentication: * CAST-128 64-bit Cipher Feedback Mode [110]RFC 2950 * CAST-128 64-bit Output Feedback Mode [111]RFC 2949 * DES3 64-bit Cipher Feedback Mode [112]RFC 2947 * DES3 64-bit Output Feedback Mode [113]RFC 2948 * DES 64-bit Cipher Feedback Mode [114]RFC 2952 * DES 64-bit Output Feedback Mode [115]RFC 2951 When the Telnet START_TLS option is negotiated, [116]SSL/TLS provides encryption services for the Telnet session. 1.4.2. FTP Encryption [ [117]Top ] [ [118]Contents ] [ [119]Chapter Contents ] [ [120]Section Contents ] [ [121]Glossary ] Encryption for FTP sessions depends on the authentication method: * Kerberos IV authentication uses DES for encryption. * Kerberos V is supported within the GSS-API framework that negotiates the encryption algorithm at run-time. The negotiated encryption algorithm depends on the implementation of GSSAPI available to Kermit. * Secure Remote Password authentication may be used with CAST-128, 3DES, DES, and Blowfish as encryption algorithms. The selected algorithm is user configurable. * SSL/TLS provides an extensive list of cipher suites for use protecting session data. 1.4.3. SSL/TLS Encryption [ [122]Top ] [ [123]Contents ] [ [124]Chapter Contents ] [ [125]Section Contents ] [ [126]Glossary ] Netscape's Secure Sockets Layer (SSL) and its IETF-approved successor, Transport Layer Security (TLS), provide for authentication and encryption of TCP/IP communications using a combination of public key and symmetric cryptographic algorithms. TLS is defined in Internet [127]RFC 2246. Traditional authentication of the server (and optionally the client) is performed by exchanging ITU-T X.509 certificate chains (see [128]Appendix 3), that are verified by the receiver. Unlike raw public keys, X.509 certificates may be revoked by issuing a certificate revocation list (CRL) that is to be checked by the receiver during verification of the certificate chain. Kerberos 5 credentials can be used as an alternative method for performing mutual authentication within SSL/TLS sessions ([129]RFC 2712). The encryption provided by SSL/TLS is more secure than the encryption negotiated by the Telnet Encryption Option. This additional security is provided by a combination of the use of longer encryption keys, the availability of stronger symmetric cryptographic algorithms, and the signing of each transmitted block with a message-digest algorithm. TLS can be used with Telnet Authentication methods such as Kerberos, Secure Remote Password, and NTLM to provide the highest level of data privacy with the strongest forms of mutual authentication when TLS in-band authentication is not performed. 1.4.4. SSH Encryption [ [130]Top ] [ [131]Contents ] [ [132]Chapter Contents ] [ [133]Section Contents ] [ [134]Glossary ] (to be filled in...) 1.4.5. HTTP Encryption [ [135]Top ] [ [136]Contents ] [ [137]Chapter Contents ] [ [138]Section Contents ] [ [139]Glossary ] Secure HTTP connections use [140]SSL/TLS for encryption. 1.4.6. Rlogin Encryption [ [141]Top ] [ [142]Contents ] [ [143]Chapter Contents ] [ [144]Section Contents ] [ [145]Glossary ] (to be filled in...) ________________________________________________________________________ 1.5. Integrity Certain security protocols including SSL/TLS, FTP SRP, FTP GSSAPI-Kerberos 5, Kerberos 5 User-to-User, and SSH not only encrypt network data streams, but also ensure that they have not been tampered with along the way. The integrity algorithms are most often MD4, MD5, or SHA-1. (details to be filled in...) ________________________________________________________________________ 2. DISCLAIMERS [ [146]Top ] [ [147]Contents ] [ [148]Glossary ] [ [149]Next ] [ [150]Previous ] The statements made with regard to US export law reflect our understanding of the situation at this writing, which might change subsequently. We expect to update this document, and our website in general, in light of any new developments. Current US law forbids export of strong encryption software in binary form from the USA to all countries except Canada without a license. Thus the Kermit Project does not distribute pre-compiled secure versions of C-Kermit on the Internet. Security within Kermit is provided using the underlying services of third-party libraries, such as Kerberos or OpenSSL. These libraries are not necessarily included with Kermit (they are with the secure version of Kermit 95, but not with C-Kermit). If not, they must be obtained separately from the sources listed below, in compliance with the terms and conditions given at those sites and with United States and international law. For an overview of this issue, see (for example): [151]http://www.mozilla.org/crypto-faq.html Kermit software, when combined with the security libraries listed in this document, has been verified to negotiate and conduct authenticated and encrypted sessions with Kerberos, SRP, and/or SSL/TLS services on Internet hosts at Columbia University and other test sites, with Kermit features such as interactive terminal access, file transfer, and scripting operating successfully over secure connections, with any exceptions noted below. The Kermit Project does not and can not claim or warrant the external Kerberos, SRP, OpenSSL or other third-party modules to be free of loopholes or bugs. Authentication via Kerberos, SRP, or X.509 certificates is not unbreakable. Any encryption method can be broken. Any software that is used for authentication or encryption should be analyzed for weaknesses, backdoors, bugs, and loopholes by the site and/or end user before use. The Kermit Project and Columbia University make no claim or warranty as to any particular level of security achievable by Kermit software with any third party security protocol, and may on no account be held liable for any damage resulting from its use (a more complete statement to this effect is found in the C-Kermit 8.0 license). Functional limitations: * Kerberos authentication is available on Telnet, FTP, Rlogin, and SSL/TLS secured connections. * Secure Remote Password authentication is available only on Telnet and FTP connections. * NTLM authentication is available only on Windows 95/98/Me/NT/2000/XP and only on Telnet connections. * SSL/TLS may be used as its own connection protocol or on Telnet, FTP, and HTTP connections. * Kerberos support is not available in Kermit 95 for OS/2 due to lack of Kerberos implementations for OS/2. * SSH is built in to the Windows version Kermit 95, but C-Kermit uses the external ssh program. [ [152]C-Kermit ] [ [153]C-Kermit 8.0 ] [ [154]Kermit 95 ] [ [155]Kermit Home ] ________________________________________________________________________ 3. KERMIT SECURITY USER GUIDE [ [156]Top ] [ [157]Contents ] [ [158]Glossary ] [ [159]Next ] [ [160]Previous ] CHAPTER CONTENTS 3.1. [161]Overview of Security Protocols 3.2. [162]Security Command List 3.3. [163]Making Secure Connections 3.4. [164]Using Secure Connections Suppose you work at a company (or are a student or faculty member at a university, or otherwised engaged in an organization of some sort) that has secure services of the kind you can access with Kermit, such as terminal sessions, file transfer, or website management. Before you can access the services securely, you have to "tell" Kermit which authentication method to use, along with any site-specific parameters, and you might also want to say what should happen if the desired type of security can't be negotiated. Bear in mind that you can use only those security methods that are offered with the services you will be connecting to. You can't just pick any old security method and expect it to work: it takes two to tango. Kermit has all the commands you need to set up secure connections, and they are the topic of this rather lengthy chapter. But don't worry: in most cases, you'll have to deal with these commands only once, and possibly not at all: * If your organization has a [165]site or bulk license for Kermit 95, the network or software license administrators in your organization should have set it all up for you in advance. * If you are setting up Kermit for your own use within an organization's security framework, you'll need to get assistance from the network administrators anyway, to find out the pertinent connection details. * In Kermit 95, there is a security form in the Dialer for any secure connections you need to make: fill it once, use it forever. * In any case, once you have put together the commands you need, you can add them to your Kermit customization file if you want them to be in effect every time you start Kermit, or you can make separate scripts for each host or organization and use them whenever needed. Therefore, this chapter is more for the system or network or security administrator than the typical end user. Given an organization that already has a security infrastructure in place, this chapter explains the Kermit commands necessary to use it. All the information should be here, but if you have trouble finding what you need or putting the pieces together, feel free to [166]send us questions by e-mail. ________________________________________________________________________ 3.1. Overview of Security Protocols SECTION CONTENTS 3.1.1. [167]Kerberos 3.1.2. [168]SRP 3.1.3. [169]NTLM 3.1.4. [170]SSL/TLS 3.1.5. [171]SSH 3.1.1. Kerberos Overview [ [172]Top ] [ [173]Contents ] [ [174]Chapter Contents ] [ [175]Section Contents ] [ [176]Glossary ] When making a Kerberized connection, you must first know which Kerberos version, 4 or 5, is supported by the host or service you want to connect to, and you must be registered in the Kerberos database at the host's site. If you're unsure about any of this, contact your site administrator. Before authentication to a specific service (such as Telnet) can succeed, you must login to the site's Kerberos Ticket Granting Server. Depending on the Kerberos implementation and installation options this might be done automatically when you log in to your operating system. Otherwise you can do it with external utilities from MIT (such as Leash, KRB5, or kinit), or with Kermit's built-in functionality, explained in this chapter. Once a Ticket Granting Ticket (TGT) is acquired, Kermit can use it to request additional tickets for each host (service) you wish to connect to. These service tickets can be used to authenticate you with the host automatically during a specified time interval, after which the tickets expire. When authentication is successful, you are logged in to the host without having to supply a user ID or password. Besides providing credentials for use during authentication, the service ticket also contains a session key to be used for encrypting the session. After the connection is authenticated, Kermit (if the necessary encryption capabilities are available) attempts to negotiate bidirectional encryption. If encryption is negotiated, it is used in one or both directions, depending on what the server agrees to. When Kerberos V authentication is used, Kermit supports credential forwarding by transferring your Ticket Granting Tickets to the host that you are connecting to, so you can make additional authenticated connections from that host to any others that accept those tickets. This provides a single sign-on capability to all the hosts and services within the Kerberos realm. Kerberos 5 authentication is one of the few authentication methods that can be used to provide verification of anonymous TLS connections. This is taken advantage of in Telnet by negotiating AUTH KRB5 after establishing a private connection with the START_TLS option. Successful operation of Kerberos requires that all machines have their dates and times synchronized. Be aware that PC clocks can drift, and this can cause authentication failures. Kerberos requires that all clocks be synchronized within 5 minutes. 3.1.2. Secure Remote Password (SRP) Overview [ [177]Top ] [ [178]Contents ] [ [179]Chapter Contents ] [ [180]Section Contents ] [ [181]Glossary ] SRP requires no special configuration of the client. When Kermit is used to connect to a host that supports SRP, the user name is transmitted automatically to the host and then a Password prompt is displayed in the Kermit command screen. This indicates that the password will not be sent to the host over the communication channel. Instead the password is used as part of a negotiation in which authentication is either mutual or none at all. The result of a mutual authentication is a shared secret used to generate two different keys for encrypting the incoming and outgoing data. SRP authentication is one of the few authentication methods that can be used to provide verification of anonymous TLS connections. The Kermit Telnet client takes advantage of this fact by by negotiating AUTH SRP after establishing a private connection with the START_TLS option. 3.1.3. NTLM Overview [ [182]Top ] [ [183]Contents ] [ [184]Chapter Contents ] [ [185]Section Contents ] [ [186]Glossary ] Microsoft's native authentication method is called (Windows) NT LAN Manager, or NTLM. It is implemented in Windows 9x/ME and NT/2000/XP and requires no configuration on the part of the user. When K95 is used on any Microsoft Windows version, it can be used as an NTLM Telnet client to authenticate to Microsoft's NT Services for Unix Telnet Server or to a K95 configured to accept incoming connections. When K95 is used on Windows NT/2000/XP it can be configured to accept incoming connections and authenticate NTLM Telnet clients. NTLM is a weak form of authentication. It provides no shared secret and cannot be used as a means of securing a connection with encryption. 3.1.4. SSLv3 and TLSv1 Overview [ [187]Top ] [ [188]Contents ] [ [189]Chapter Contents ] [ [190]Section Contents ] [ [191]Glossary ] (Also see [192]Appendix III for an introduction to the concept of certificates.) Secure Sockets Layer Version 3 (SSLv3) and its successor Transport Layer Security Version 1 (TLSv1) ([193]RFC 2246) were originally developed for Web browsing. They provide a framework for using public-key certificates or Kerberos 5 to negotiate server and (optionally) client authentication and bidirectional encryption. The encryption provided by SSLv3 and TLSv1 is stronger than that provided by the Telnet Encryption option. SSLv3 and TLSv1 connections may be negotiated in two different ways. First, the connection may be SSL/TLS-only, which is used when connecting to HTTPS services or SSL/TLS tunnels. SSL/TLS can also be negotiated after the connection is established via negotiations performed in some other protocol (such as Telnet START_TLS.) Kermit supports both methods: * Pure SSLv3 connections via SET HOST host port /SSL * Pure TLSv1 connections via SET HOST host port /TLS * SSLv3 connections negotiated by Tim Hudson's Telnet AUTH SSL option * TLSv1 connections negotiated by the IETF TN3270E Working Group's TELNET START_TLS option * SSLv3 and TLSv1 connections negotiated with FTP OPEN host port * SSLv3 and TLSv1 connections negotiated with HTTP OPEN host port In their most common use, SSL and TLS negotiations provide the client with authentication of the host computer when the host's X.509 certificate is verified or when Kerberos 5 is used. The client can be authenticated with an X.509 certificate issued to the end user, or with Kerberos 5, or with one of the supported Telnet authentication methods. Even though the data channel is encrypted, the transmission of passwords to the host should still be avoided to prevent theft by a compromised host. If certificates are to be verified, the root certificates of the certificate authorities (CAs) must be available. If you are not acting as your own CA you need a file containing the root certificates that were used to sign the certificates belonging to the servers you want to authenticate. A compilation of most of the commercial Certificate Authority root certificates as extracted from Microsoft Windows XP's certificate database is available at: [194]ftp://kermit.columbia.edu/kermit/c-kermit/ca_certs.pem Once the file is downloaded, you can tell Kermit where it is with the following command ([195]Section 3.2.2.3): SET AUTH SSL VERIFY-FILE path/ca_certs.pem When Kermit is acting as an [196]Internet Kermit Service daemon (IKSD), client certificates can be used for automatic login. If a certificate-to-userid mapping function is provided, the IKSD logs the user in automatically if the certificate is verified and the specified userid exists. Kermit also supports the use of a ".tlslogin" file that allows a certificate to be used to login automatically to an account without a certificate-to-userid mapping function. When Kermit receives a username via the Telnet New-Environment variable after it has received and verified a client certificate, it looks in the home directory corresponding to the username for a file called ".tlslogin". If the file contains the certificate presented by the client, the client is logged in as the requested user without a password. See [197]Appendix III for information on certificate to user mapping. The method for negotiating Tim Hudson's Telnet AUTH SSL option is open to a "man-in-the-middle" attack which is capable of disabling the use of SSL before the negotiation is begun. It should be used only with: SET TELNET AUTHENTICATION TYPE SSL SET TELOPT AUTHENTICATION REQUIRED When using IKSD with START_TLS you should create an /etc/iksd.conf including Kermit commands that point to the certificate and key files: set auth tls rsa-cert-file /usr/local/ssl/certs/telnetd-rsa.pem set auth tls rsa-key-file /usr/local/ssl/certs/telnetd-rsa-key.pem set auth tls dsa-cert-file /usr/local/ssl/certs/telnetd-dsa.pem set auth tls dsa-key-file /usr/local/ssl/certs/telnetd-dsa-key.pem as well as the list of acceptable ciphers: set auth tls cipher 3DES:DSS If your server certificate was signed by an intermediary certificate authority instead of a root, you must provide the full chain of intermediary certificates for the client to be able to authenticate your server. These certificates can be specified with: set auth tls rsa-cert-chain-file /usr/local/ssl/certs/telnetd-rsa-chain.pem set auth tls dsa-cert-chain-file /usr/local/ssl/certs/telnetd-dsa-chain.pem The SSL and TLS handshake can be very time-consuming, and therefore Kermit can cache your your SSL/TLS sessions. When Kermit is used with a peer that supports cached sessions, subsequent connections to the same host can be securely established in a fraction of the time necessary for the initial connection. This is especially important for FTP and HTTP, which can make many connections to the same host during during a typical session. For a list of Telnet servers that support START_TLS see [198]Section I.1 of [199]Appendix I. For a list of FTP servers that support AUTH SSL and AUTH TLS see [200]Section I.2. 3.1.5. SSH v1 and v2 Overview [ [201]Top ] [ [202]Contents ] [ [203]Chapter Contents ] [ [204]Section Contents ] [ [205]Glossary ] (To be filled in...) ________________________________________________________________________ 3.2. Security Command List [ [206]Top ] [ [207]Contents ] [ [208]Chapter Contents ] [ [209]Glossary ] SECTION CONTENTS 3.2.1. [210]Connection Establishment 3.2.2. [211]The SET AUTHENTICATION Command 3.2.3. [212]The AUTHENTICATE Command 3.2.4. [213]Other Security-Related Commands The following notation is used in Kermit command syntax descriptions: KEYWORD Command keywords are shown in boldface. These are literal words to be used in the command. Alphabetic case does not matter. Keywords can be abbreviated to any degree that does not produce a conflict with any other keyword that can be used in the same position. parameter Parameter names are shown in italics; they are to be replaced by an actual value; for example, number might be replaced by 123, and filename might be replaced by oofa.txt. [ thing ] Any item enclosed in italicized square brackets is optional; that is, it can be omitted. { thing1, thing2, ... } Italicized curly braces enclose a list of choices: pick one. oofa.txt Typewriter font is used for computer messages, dialogs, code, and filenames. In all Kermit commands: * KERBEROS4 can be abbreviated KRB4 or K4 * KERBEROS5 can be abbreviated KRB5 or K5 Some of Kermit's Kerberos-related commands are rather complex, but remember that you don't have to memorize them, or any other Kermit commands. Use "?" at any point to feel your way through the command, or type HELP for the desired command to see a brief explanation. If you would like to have a tutorial in Kermit basics before proceeding, please visit: The C-Kermit Tutorial [214]http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ckututor.html The Kermit 95 Tutorial [215]http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/k95tutor.html Kermit Script Tutorial and Library [216]http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ckscripts.html Before you try to make any secure connections, you should check whether your version of Kermit has the required capabilities. The SHOW FEATURES command lists the security methods that are and are not included. In addition the following commands can be used (typically in scripts) to check for specific security features: CHECK KERBEROS tells whether your version of Kermit has been built to include Kerberos protocol (even if it cannot function on your system). Succeeds if Kerberos is included, fails if it isn't. The CHECK command can be used in scripts like this: check kerberos if success { Commands to execute if Kerberos is built in. } else { Commands to execute if Kerberos is not built in. } CHECK NTLM Tells whether your version of Kermit has been built to include the NTLM support even if it cannot function on your system, and succeeds or fails accordingly. CHECK SRP Tells whether your version of Kermit has been built to include SRP protocols. Succeeds or fails accordingly. CHECK SSL/TLS Tells whether your version of Kermit has been built to include SSL/TLS (even if it cannot function on your system). Succeeds or fails accordingly. IF AVAILABLE ENCRYPTION command Executes the command if session encryption is available in your version of Kermit (e.g. in K95 if the K95CRYPT.DLL file is installed on your PC). Example: if available encryption set telnet encryption type cast128_cfb64 IF AVAILABLE KERBEROS4 command Executes the command if Kerberos 4 is available in your version of Kermit (e.g. if the Kerberos 4 DLLs are installed on your PC). IF AVAILABLE KERBEROS5 command Executes the command if Kerberos 5 is available in your version of Kermit. IF AVAILABLE NTLM command Executes the command if Microsoft NT LAN Manager protocol is available in your version of Kermit. IF AVAILABLE SRP command Executes the command if Secure Remote Password protocol is available in your version of Kermit. IF AVAILABLE { SSL, TLS } command Executes the command if SSL/TLS protocol is available in your version of Kermit. ________________________________________________________________________ 3.2.1. Connection Establishment [ [217]Top ] [ [218]Contents ] [ [219]Chapter Contents ] [ [220]Section Contents ] [ [221]Glossary ] SUBSECTION CONTENTS 3.2.1.1. [222]Making Secure Telnet Connections 3.2.1.2. [223]Making Secure FTP Connections 3.2.1.3. [224]Making Secure HTTP Connections 3.2.1.1. Secure TELNET Connections [ [225]Top ] [ [226]Contents ] [ [227]Chapter Contents ] [ [228]Section Contents ] [ [229]Subsection Contents ] [ [230]Glossary ] The Telnet protocol is one of the most flexible protocols ever used on computer networks, and therefore can be somewhat complicated when its advanced options come into play. Kermit has commands to manage every aspect of the Telnet connection. Kermit's Telnet engine and related commands are thoroughly described in the Kermit Telnet Reference: [231]http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/telnet.html (which you should read if you're not familiar with Kermit's Telnet client). This section focuses on Telnet-related commands for making secure connections. Four Telnet Options can be negotiated between a Telnet client and server that affect secure connections: AUTH, ENCRYPT, START_TLS, and FORWARD_X. When people talk about Telnet not being secure they are referring to Telnet clients and servers that can't negotiate any of these four options (because they have not been coded to do so). That does not mean that secure Telnet clients (such as Kermit) and servers ([232]Appendix I) are not readily available. Telnet sessions always begin in an insecure state. Only after the initial negotiations are complete can the session be secured. Security in Telnet can be established using many combinations of Telnet Options and authentication and encryption methods. The AUTH option negotiates whether authentication is to be used for the current session, and if so, which type of authentication. The authentication type is determined by the server offering an ordered list of types and the client choosing the most preferred type that it supports. Most forms of authentication generate a shared secret that can be used with the ENCRYPT option for privacy. The How and Encrypt flags specify an authentication mode and whether encryption is required for this connection. The AUTH option can be negotiated with either the START_TLS or the ENCRYPT option, but not both. The following commands control Kermit's Telnet security negotiation policies and procedures: SET TELOPT [ { /CLIENT, /SERVER } ] AUTHENTICATION { ACCEPTED, REFUSED, REQUESTED, REQUIRED } Tells Kermit to ACCEPT or REFUSE authentication bids, or actively REQUEST authentication. REQUIRED refuses and closes the connection if authentication is not successfully negotiated when either making or accepting connections. The default is REQUESTED. SET TELNET AUTHENTICATION TYPE { AUTOMATIC, KERBEROS4, KERBEROS5, NTLM, SRP, SSL, NONE } AUTOMATIC is the default. Available options can vary depending on the features Kermit was built to support and the operating system configuration; type "set telnet auth type ?" for a list (Hint: keywords in Kermit commands can be abbreviated). When Kermit is the Telnet client: AUTOMATIC allows the host to choose the preferred type of authentication. NONE instructs Kermit to refuse all authentication methods when the authentication option is negotiated. A list of one or more other values allow a specific subset of the supported authentication methods to be used. When Kermit is the Telnet server: AUTOMATIC results in available authentication methods being offered to the Telnet client in the following order: KERBEROS_V, KERBEROS_IV, SRP, SSL, NTLM. NONE results in no authentication methods being offered to the Telnet server when the authentication option is negotiated. The preferred method of disabling authentication is with SET TELOPT /SERVER AUTHENTICATION REFUSE. A list of one or more authentication methods specifies the order those methods are to be offered to the telnet client. If you wish to allow NTLM authentication to be used with the Microsoft Windows 2000 or Services for Unix Telnet client you must specify a list with NTLM as the first item in the list. By default, NTLM is the last item in the list because it does not provide any form of data encryption. SET TELNET AUTHENTICATION HOW-FLAG { ANY, MUTUAL, ONE-WAY } Specifies which values for the HOW-FLAG should be accepted as a client or offered as a server. The default is ANY. SET TELNET AUTHENTICATION ENCRYPT-FLAG { ANY, NONE, TELOPT, TLS } Specifies which values for the ENCRYPT-FLAG should be accepted as a client or offered as a server. The default is ANY. The Telnet protocol ENCRYPT option is used to negotiate whether streaming ciphers are to be used to protect the privacy of the connection, and if so, which encryption type to use in each direction. The encryption type is determined by each side offering the list of types it can use to receive data. Then the sender chooses the first type that it supports from the list. The ENCRYPT option cannot be negotiated without the AUTH option. Whenever both START_TLS and ENCRYPT are both available, START_TLS is used since TLS provides both privacy and integrity to the data stream. SET TELOPT [ { /CLIENT, /SERVER } ] ENCRYPTION { ACCEPTED, REFUSED, REQUESTED, REQUIRED } { ACCEPTED, REFUSED, REQUESTED, REQUIRED } The first parameter specifies the Kermit-to-peer state. The second parameter specifies the peer-to-Kermit state. The default is ACCEPTED REQUESTED: Kermit accepts encryption if offered, and requests it in case it is not offered. SET TELNET ENCRYPTION TYPE { AUTOMATIC, CAST128_CFB64, CAST128_OFB64, CAST5_40_CFB64, CAST5_40_OFB64, DES_CFB64, DES_OFB64, DES3_CFB64, DES3_OFB64, NONE } AUTOMATIC allows the host to choose the preferred type of encryption. Other values allow a specific encryption method to be specified. AUTOMATIC is the default. The list of options varies depending on the encryption types selected when Kermit was compiled. An encryption method can be used only if there is enough key data available. Kerberos 4 can use only DES encryption because it provides a shared secret just 56 bits in length. The START_TLS option negotiates whether the current session is to be protected by Transport Layer Security (TLS), the same protocol used to secure all of the HTTP Web sites on the Internet. TLS uses X.509 certificates or Kerberos 5 credentials to authenticate the server and optionally authenticate the client. START_TLS can be used with AUTH to allow Kerberos, Secure Remote Password, or other authentication methods to be used to authenticate the client. START_TLS can not be used with the ENCRYPT option. Nor is there any need to since the protection provided by TLS is stronger than all of the streaming ciphers supported by the ENCRYPT option. SET TELOPT [ { /CLIENT, /SERVER } ] START_TLS { ACCEPTED, REFUSED, REQUESTED, REQUIRED } ACCEPT or REFUSE a request to negotiate TLS, or actively REQUEST that TLS be negotiated. REQUIRED refuses and closes the connection if the peer refuses to negotiate TLS or the TLS negotiations end in failure. ACCEPTED by default when a client. REQUESTED by default when a server. After the Telnet session is established and protected, it is possible to use it to protect the data associated with X Windows System clients started on the remote host via the Telnet session. The FORWARD_X option is used to negotiate and implement the protection of X Windows Systems data. SET TELOPT [ { /CLIENT } ] FORWARD_X { ACCEPTED, REFUSED, REQUESTED, REQUIRED } ACCEPT or REFUSE a request to negotiate FORWARD_X, or actively REQUEST that FORWARD_X be negotiated. REQUIRED refuses and closes the connection if the peer refuses to negotiate FORWARD_X or the FORWARD_X negotiations end in failure. ACCEPTED by default when a client. Kermit does not support FORWARD_X when it is a server. After a Telnet session is authenticated and protected it is possible to forward the credentials used to authenticate the session to the host. When credentials are forwarded to the host you do not need to enter your password when making additional connections from it. This is referred to as Single Sign-On. Credentials forwarding is currently only supported when the authentication method is Kerberos 5. SET TELNET AUTHENTICATION FORWARDING { ON, OFF } When Kermit is the client, set this to ON to forward forwardable Kerberos V Ticket Granting Tickets to the host after authentication is complete, so you can make additional authenticated connections from there. When Kermit is the server, set this to ON to accept forwardable Kerberos V TGTs from the client. OFF by default. When establishing a secure connection there are potentially three usernames associated with the connection: the name of the user on the local machine; the name under which the user authenticates (the Kerberos principal name or X.509 certificate name); and the name the user wants to login as. The login name can be set with either of the following commands: SET TELNET ENVIRONMENT USER name SET LOGIN USERID name If a name is given, it sent to host during Telnet negotiations; if this switch is given but the string is omitted, no user ID is sent to the host. If this command is not given, your current USERID value, \v(userid), is sent. When a userid is sent to the host it is a request to login as the specified user. All forms of authentication rely on some secret information that only the user (or service) being authenticated knows or has in their possession. Before Kermit can authenticate as the user it must acquire this secret information. This is usually done by prompting the user for the necessary information at the time of authentication. But what if you need to automate the process? The SET LOGIN PASSWORD command can be used to specify the password to Kermit prior to establishing the connection. However, we strongly advise that this command be used in a script that prompts for the password and then establishes the automated connection later. Storing a password in a script file defeats all of the hard work you have done to secure your connections. An NTLM user ID consists of both a DOMAIN and a username. This is set in Kermit as SET LOGIN USER DOMAIN\\username due to the use of backslash (\) as the command quote character in Kermit's command language. SET LOGIN PASSWORD password If a password is given, it is treated as the password to be used (if required) by any Telnet Authentication protocol (Kerberos Ticket retrieval, Secure Remote Password (SRP), or X.509 certificate private key decryption). If no password is specified a prompt is issued to request the password if one is required for the negotiated authentication method. If things go wrong when establishing a secure connection it is useful to be able to watch the telnet negotiations. Even when things go smoothly it can be fun to watch all of the action. SET TELNET DEBUG ON Displays all TELNET negotiations in full detail. ______________________________________________________________________ 3.2.1.2. Secure FTP Connections [ [233]Top ] [ [234]Contents ] [ [235]Chapter Contents ] [ [236]Section Contents ] [ [237]Subsection Contents ] [ [238]Glossary ] C-Kermit 8.0 and Kermit 95 2.00 provide support for authenticated and encrypted file transfers using Kerberos 4, GSSAPI-Kerberos 5, Secure Remote Password (SRP), Secure Sockets Layer (SSL), and Transport Layer Security (TLS). Complete details on how to use the FTP support can be found at the [239]Kermit website. Here we explain how to make secure FTP connections (server willing) with the FTP OPEN command: FTP [ OPEN [ { /SSL, /TLS } ] ] hostname [ port ] [ switches ] Opens a connection to the FTP server on the given host. The default TCP port is 21 (or 990 if /SSL or /TLS are specified), but a different port number can be supplied if necessary. /SSL or /TLS should be used if the FTP daemon is accessed through an SSL Proxy Server. Optional switches are: /ANONYMOUS Logs you in anonymously. /USER:text Supplies the given text as your username. /PASSWORD:text Supplies the given text as your password. If you include a username but omit this switch and the server requires a password, you are prompted for it. /ACCOUNT:text Supplies the given text as your account, if required by the server. /ACTIVE Forces an active (rather than passive) connection. /PASSIVE Forces a passive (rather than active) connection. The following commands configure the use of FTP Security when establishing connections: SET FTP AUTHTYPE list Specifies an ordered list of authentication methods to be attempted when FTP AUTOAUTHENTICATION is ON. The default list is: GSSAPI-KRB5, SRP, KERBEROS_V4, TLS, SSL. If none of the specified methods are supported by the server, an insecure login is used as a fallback. It should be noted that TLS and SSL can be used to secure an anonymous connection. SET FTP AUTOAUTHENTICATION { ON, OFF } Specifies whether or not authentication should be negotiated by the FTP OPEN command. Default is ON. SET FTP AUTOENCRYPTION { ON, OFF } Specifies whether encryption and message integrity (privacy) should be negotiated by the FTP OPEN command. Default is ON. SET FTP AUTOLOGIN { ON, OFF } Tells Kermit whether to try to automatically log you in (using the FTP USER command) during the FTP OPEN command. Default is ON. SET FTP COMMAND-PROTECTION-LEVEL { CLEAR, CONFIDENTIAL, PRIVATE, SAFE } Tells what level of protection is applied to the FTP command channel. CLEAR means no protection at all. CONFIDENTIAL means the messages are encrypted but not integrity protected. PRIVATE means the messages are encrypted and integrity protected. SAFE means the messages are integrity protected but not encrypted. SET FTP CREDENTIAL-FORWARDING { ON, OFF } Specifies whether end-user credentials are to be forwarded to the server if supported by the authentication method. At the moment only GSSAPI-KRB5 supports credentials forwarding. SET FTP DATA-PROTECTION-LEVEL { CLEAR, CONFIDENTIAL, PRIVATE, SAFE } Tells what level of protection is applied to the FTP data channel. The levels are the same as for SET FTP COMMAND-PROTECTION-LEVEL. SET FTP SRP CIPHER cipher Specifies a cipher to be used to encrypt FTP data if SRP security is negotiated. The default cipher is DES3_ECB. SET FTP SRP HASH hash Specifies a hash to be used to integrity protect FTP data if SRP security is negotiated. The default hash is SHA1. ______________________________________________________________________ 3.2.1.3. Secure HTTP Connections [ [240]Top ] [ [241]Contents ] [ [242]Chapter Contents ] [ [243]Section Contents ] [ [244]Subsection Contents ] [ [245]Glossary ] C-Kermit 8.0 and Kermit 95 2.00 provide support for secure HTTP requests via the use of SSL or TLS. Secure connections are established automatically when the destination service name is "https" or the port number is 443. Alternatively, SSL or TLS may be utilized with arbitrary port numbers if you include the appropriate switch in the HTTP OPEN command: HTTP [ switches ] OPEN [ { /SSL, /TLS } ] hostname [ service/port ] Instructs Kermit to open a new connection for HTTP communication with the specified host on the specified port. The default port is "http" (80). If /SSL or /TLS are specified a secure connection is established. If switches are specified, they are applied to all subsequent HTTP actions (GET, PUT, ...) until an HTTP CLOSE command has been executed. ________________________________________________________________________ 3.2.2. The SET AUTHENTICATION Command [ [246]Top ] [ [247]Contents ] [ [248]Chapter Contents ] [ [249]Section Contents ] [ [250]Glossary ] The SET AUTHENTICATION command lets you configure Kermit's authentication methods and set defaults for the [251]AUTHENTICATE command so you don't always have to include all the switches if you give more than one AUTHENTICATE command in a Kermit session. If you always use the same setup, you can put the appropriate SET AUTHENTICATION commands in your Kermit customization file: K95CUSTOM.INI (Windows) or ~/.mykermrc (UNIX). 3.2.2.1. SET AUTHENTICATION Commands for Kerberos SET AUTHENTICATION { KERBEROS5 } ADDRESSES { list-of-IP-addresses } When a list of IP addresses is specified, these addresses are added to the contents of Kerberos 5 tickets retrieved via Kermit commands. SET AUTHENTICATION { KERBEROS4, KERBEROS5 } AUTODESTROY { ON-CLOSE, ON-EXIT, NEVER } When ON, Kermit destroys all credentials in the default credentials cache upon Kermit termination. Default is NEVER. SET AUTHENTICATION { KERBEROS4, KERBEROS5 } AUTOGET { ON, OFF } When ON and the protocol is TELNET or FTP, if the host offers Kerberos 4 or Kerberos 5 authentication and Kermit is configured to use that authentication method and there is no TGT, Kermit automatically attempts to retrieve one by prompting for the password (and principal if needed.) Default is ON. SET AUTHENTICATION KERBEROS5 CREDENTIALS-CACHE cache-name Specifies an alternative credentials cache, useful when you need to maintain two or more sets of credentials for different realms or roles. The default is specified by the environment variable KRB5CCNAME or as reported by the Kerberos 5 library. SET AUTHENTICATION { KERBEROS4, KERBEROS5 } CHECK-ADDRESSES { ON, OFF } When ON, Kermit uses the embedded IP address(es) in the ticket to determine validity. When OFF, IP addresses are ignored by Kermit. The default is ON. SET AUTHENTICATION KERBEROS5 FORWARDABLE { ON, OFF } ON specifies that Kerberos 5 credentials should be forwardable to the host. If SET TELNET AUTHENTICATION FORWARDING is ON, forwardable credentials are sent to the host. Default is OFF. SET AUTHENTICATION KERBEROS5 GET-K4-TGT { ON, OFF } ON specifies that Kerberos 4 credentials should be requested each time Kerberos 5 credentials are requested with AUTH KERBEROS5 INIT. The default is OFF. SET AUTHENTICATION KERBEROS4 INSTANCE instance Allows a Kerberos 4 instance to be specified as a default (if needed). SET AUTHENTICATION { KERBEROS4, KERBEROS5 } LIFETIME minutes Specifies the lifetime of the TGTs requested from the KDC. The default is 600 minutes (10 hours). SET AUTHENTICATION KERBEROS5 NO-ADDRESSES { ON, OFF } Kerberos 5 tickets contain a list of all of the IP addresses associated with the computer used to acquire them. This allows the recipient of a ticket to check whether it came from the machine to which it was issued, and makes stolen Kerberos tickets useless. [252]Network Address Translators and other Proxy services have the side effect of changing the IP address from which a connection appears to originate. This causes the IP address check to fail and for Kerberos 5 tickets to be rejected as invalid. When ON, the NO-ADDRESSES command prevents the inclusion of IP addresses in Kerberos 5 tickets retrieved with Kermit's AUTHENTICATE KERBEROS5 INIT command enabling the tickets to be accepted from any host. SET AUTHENTICATION KERBEROS4 PREAUTH { ON, OFF } Allows Kerberos 4 preauthenticated TGT requests to be turned off. The default is ON. Only use if absolutely necessary. We recommend that preauthenticated requests be required for all tickets returned by a KDC to a requestor. SET AUTHENTICATION { KERBEROS4, KERBEROS5 } PRINCIPAL name When Kermit starts, it attempts to set the principal name to that stored in the current credentials cache. If no credential cache exists, the current SET LOGIN USERID value is used. SET LOGIN USERID is set to the operating systems current username when Kermit is started. To force Kermit to prompt the user for the principal name when requesting TGTs, place: SET AUTH K4 PRINCIPAL {} SET AUTH K5 PRINCIPAL {} in the Kermit initialization file or connection script. SET AUTHENTICATION { KERBEROS4, KERBEROS5 } PROMPT PASSWORD prompt Specifies a custom prompt to be used when prompting for a password. The Kerberos prompt strings may contain two "%s" replacement fields. The first %s is replaced by the principal name; the second by the realm. SET AUTHENTICATION { KERBEROS4, KERBEROS5 } PROMPT PRINCIPAL prompt Specifies a custom prompt to be used when prompting for the Kerberos principal name. No %s replacement fields may be included. Kermit prompts for a principal name when retrieving a TGT if the command: SET AUTHENTICATION { KERBEROS4, KERBEROS5 } PRINCIPAL {} has been issued. SET AUTHENTICATION KERBEROS5 PROXIABLE { ON, OFF } When ON, specifies that Kerberos 5 credentials should be proxiable. The default is OFF. SET AUTHENTICATION KERBEROS5 RENEWABLE minutes When minutes is greater than the ticket lifetime a TGT may be renewed with AUTH K5 INIT /RENEW instead of granting a new ticket as long as the ticket is not expired and it's within the renewable lifetime. Default is 0 (zero) minutes. SET AUTHENTICATION { KERBEROS4, KERBEROS5 } REALM name If no default is set, the default realm configured for the Kerberos libraries is used. Abbreviations are accepted. SET AUTHENTICATION { KERBEROS4, KERBEROS5 } SERVICE-NAME name This command specifies the service ticket name used to authenticate to the host when Kermit is used as a client; or the service ticket name accepted by Kermit when it is acting as the host. If no default is set, the default service name for Kerberos 4 is "rcmd" and for Kerberos 5 is "host". 3.2.2.2. SET AUTHENTICATION Commands for SRP SET AUTHENTICATION SRP PROMPT PASSWORD text Specifies a custom prompt to be used when prompting for a password. prompt may contain a single instance of "%s" to be replaced by the user's login name. 3.2.2.3. SET AUTHENTICATION Commands for SSL/TLS In all of the following commands "SSL" and "TLS" are aliases. SET AUTHENTICATION { SSL, TLS } CIPHER-LIST list-of-ciphers This command applies to both SSL and TLS. A colon-separated list of any of the following (case-sensitive) options is accepted, depending on the options chosen when OpenSSL was compiled: Key Exchange Algorithms: kRSA: RSA key exchange kDHr: Diffie-Hellman key exchange (key from RSA cert) kDHd: Diffie-Hellman key exchange (key from DSA cert) kEDH: Ephemeral Diffie-Hellman key exchange (temporary key) kKRB5: Kerberos 5 Authentication Algorithm: aNULL: No authentication aRSA: RSA authentication aDSS: DSS authentication aDH: Diffie-Hellman authentication aKRB5: Kerberos 5 Cipher Encoding Algorithm: eNULL: No encoding AES256: 256-bit AES encoding AES128: 128-bit AES encoding DES: DES encoding 3DES: Triple DES encoding RC4: RC4 encoding RC2: RC2 encoding IDEA: IDEA encoding MAC Digest Algorithm: MD5: MD5 hash function SHA1: SHA1 hash function SHA: SHA hash function (should not be used) Aliases: ALL: all ciphers SSLv2: all SSL version 2.0 ciphers (should not be used) SSLv3: all SSL version 3.0 ciphers EXP: all export ciphers (40-bit) EXPORT56: all export ciphers (56-bit) LOW: all low strength ciphers (no export) MEDIUM: all ciphers with 128-bit encryption HIGH: all ciphers using greater than 128-bit encryption RSA: all ciphers using RSA key exchange DH: all ciphers using Diffie-Hellman key exchange EDH: all ciphers using Ephemeral Diffie-Hellman key exchange ADH: all ciphers using Anonymous Diffie-Hellman key exchange DSS: all ciphers using DSS authentication KRB5: all ciphers using Kerberos 5 AES: all ciphers using AES NULL: all ciphers using no encryption Each item in the list may include a prefix modifier: "+" Move cipher(s) to the current location in the list "-" Remove cipher(s) from the list (may be added again by a subsequent list entry) "!" Kill cipher from the list (it may not be added again by a subsequent list entry) If no modifier is specified the entry is added to the list at the current position. "+" may also be used to combine tags to specify entries such as "RSA+RC4" describes all ciphers that use both RSA and RC4. For example, all available ciphers not including ADH key exchange: ALL:!ADH:RC4+RSA:+HIGH:+MEDIUM:+LOW:+SSLv2:+EXP All algorithms including ADH and export but excluding patented algorithms: HIGH:MEDIUM:LOW:EXPORT56:EXP:ADH:!kRSA:!aRSA:!RC4:!RC2:!IDEA The OpenSSL command: openssl ciphers -v list-of-ciphers may be used to list all of the ciphers and the order described by a specific list-of-ciphers. SET AUTHENTICATION { SSL, TLS } CRL-DIR directory Specifies a directory that contains certificate revocation files, where each file is named by the hash of the certificate issuer name. OpenSSL expects the hash symlinks to be made like this: ln -s crl.pem `openssl crl -hash -noout -in crl.pem`.r0 Since all file systems do not have symlinks you can use the following command in Kermit to copy the crl.pem file to the hash file name: copy crl.pem {\fcommand(openssl crl -hash -noout -in crl.pem).r0} This produces a hash based on the issuer field in the CRL such that the issuer field of a Cert may be quickly mapped to the correct CRL. In Kermit 95, the default directory is \v(exedir)crls SET AUTHENTICATION { SSL, TLS } CRL-FILE filename Specifies a file that contains certificate revocations used to reject the validation of certificates. In Kermit 95, the default file is \v(exedir)ca_crls.pem SET AUTHENTICATION { SSL, TLS } DEBUG { ON, OFF } Tells whether debug information should be displayed about the SSL/TLS connection. When DEBUG is ON, the VERIFY command does not terminate connections when set to FAIL-IF-NO-PEER-CERT and a certificate is presented that cannot be successfully verified; instead each error is displayed but the connection automatically continues. SET AUTHENTICATION { SSL, TLS } DH-PARAM-FILE filename Specifies a file containing DH parameters used to generate temporary DH keys. If a DH parameter file is not provided Kermit uses a fixed set of parameters depending on the negotiated key length. Kermit provides DH parameters for key lengths of 512, 768, 1024, 1536, and 2048 bits. SET AUTHENTICATION { SSL, TLS } DSA-CERT-CHAIN-FILE filename Specifies a file containing a DSA certificate chain to be sent along with the DSA-CERT to the peer. This file must only be specified if Kermit is being used as a server and the DSA certificate was signed by an intermediary certificate authority. SET AUTHENTICATION { SSL, TLS } DSA-CERT-FILE filename Specifies a file containing a DSA certificate to be sent to the peer to authenticate the host or end user. The file may contain the matching DH private key instead of using the DSA-KEY-FILE command. SET AUTHENTICATION { SSL, TLS } DSA-KEY-FILE filename Specifies a file containing the private DH key that matches the DSA certificate specified with DSA-CERT-FILE. This command is only necessary if the private key is not appended to the certificate in the file specified by DSA-CERT-FILE. Note: When Kermit is running as an IKSD it cannot support encrypted private keys. If your private key file is encrypted you can use the following command to unencrypt it (provided you know that pass phrase): openssl dsa -in encrypted-key-file -out unencrypted-key-file SET AUTHENTICATION { SSL, TLS } RANDOM-FILE filename Specifies a file containing random data to be used when initializing the Pseudo Random Number Generator (PRNG) engine. This file is overwritten with new random data after the file is read. SET AUTHENTICATION { SSL, TLS } RSA-CERT-CHAIN-FILE filename Specifies a file containing a RSA certificate chain to be sent along with the RSA-CERT to the peer. This file must only be specified if Kermit is being used as a server and the RSA certificate was signed by an intermediary certificate authority. SET AUTHENTICATION { SSL, TLS } RSA-CERT-FILE filename Specifies a file containing a RSA certificate to be sent to the peer to authenticate the host or end user. The file may contain the matching RSA private key instead of using the RSA-KEY-FILE command. SET AUTHENTICATION { SSL, TLS } RSA-KEY-FILE filename Specifies a file containing the private RSA key that matches the RSA certificate specified with RSA-CERT-FILE. This command is only necessary if the private key is not appended to the certificate in the file specified by RSA-CERT-FILE. Note: When Kermit is running as an IKSD it cannot support encrypted private keys. If your private key file is encrypted you can use the following command to unencrypt it (provided you know that pass phrase): openssl rsa -in encrypted-key-file -out unencrypted-key-file SET AUTHENTICATION { SSL, TLS } VERBOSE { ON, OFF } Specifies whether information about the authentication (the certificate chain) should be displayed when making a connection. SET AUTHENTICATION { SSL, TLS } VERIFY { NO, PEER-CERT, FAIL-IF-NO-PEER-CERT } Specifies whether certificates should be requested from the peer; whether they should be verified when they are presented; and whether they should be required. When set to NO (the default for IKSD), Kermit does not request that the peer send a certificate and if one is presented it is ignored. When set to PEER-CERT (the default when not IKSD), Kermit requests a certificate be sent by the peer. If the certificate is presented, it is verified. Any errors during the verification process result in queries to the end user. When set to FAIL-IF-NO-PEER-CERT, Kermit asks the peer to send a certificate. If the certificate is not presented or fails to verify successfully, the connection is terminated without querying the user. If an anonymous cipher (i.e., ADH) is desired the NO setting must be used; otherwise the receipt of the peer certificate request is interpreted as a protocol error and the negotiation fails. If you wish to allow the peer to authenticate using either an X.509 certificate to userid mapping function or via use of a ~/.tlslogin file, you must use either PEER-CERT or FAIL-IF-NO-PEER-CERT. Otherwise, any certificates that are presented are ignored. In other words, use NO if you want to disable the ability to use certificates to authenticate a peer. SET AUTHENTICATION { SSL, TLS } VERIFY-DIR directory Specifies a directory that contains root CA certificate files used to verify the certificate chains presented by the peer. Each file is named by a hash of the certificate. OpenSSL expects the hash symlinks to be made like this: ln -s cert.pem `openssl x509 -hash -noout -in cert.pem`.0 Since all file systems do not have symlinks you can use the following command in Kermit to copy the cert.pem file to the hash file name: copy cert.pem {\fcommand(openssl x509 -hash -noout -in cert.pem).0} This produces a hash based on the subject field in the cert such that the certificate may be quickly found. In Kermit 95, the default directory is \v(exedir)certs SET AUTHENTICATION { SSL, TLS } VERIFY-FILE file Specifies a file that contains root CA certificates to be used for verifying certificate chains. In Kermit 95, the default file is \v(exedir)ca_certs.pem 3.2.3. The AUTHENTICATE Command (Kerberos Only) [ [253]Top ] [ [254]Contents ] [ [255]Chapter Contents ] [ [256]Section Contents ] [ [257]Glossary ] The AUTHENTICATE command obtains or destroys Kerberos tickets and lists information about them. The general format is: AUTHENTICATE { KERBEROS4, KERBEROS5 [ switches ] } action [ switches ] The use of command switches is described in [258]Section 1.5 of the [259]C-Kermit 7.0 Update Notes. The actions are INITIALIZE, DESTROY, and LIST-CREDENTIALS. The AUTHENTICATE command's INITIALIZE option is the most complex of Kermit's security commands, and its format is different for Kerberos 4 and Kerberos 5: Kerberos 4: AUTH K4 INITIALIZE [ k4-switches ] [ principal ] Kerberos 5: AUTH K5 [ k5-switches ] { INITIALIZE ..., DESTROY, LIST-CREDENTIALS, ...} AUTHENTICATE K4 INITIALIZE switches (all optional): /INSTANCE:name Allows an Instance to be specified (see Glossary). /LIFETIME:number Specifies the requested lifetime in minutes for the ticket. If no lifetime is specified, 600 minutes is used. If the lifetime is greater than the maximum supported by the ticket granting service, the resulting lifetime is shortened accordingly. /NOT-PREAUTH Instructs Kermit to send a ticket granting ticket (TGT) request to the KDC without any preauthentication data. /PASSWORD:string Allows the inclusion of a password in a script file. If no /PASSWORD switch is included, you are prompted on a separate line. The password switch is provided for use by automated scripts. However, we strongly recommend that it not be used because clear-text passwords are easily compromised. /PREAUTH Instructs Kermit to send a preauthenticated ticket granting ticket (TGT) request to the KDC instead of a plaintext request. The default when supported by the Kerberos libraries. /REALM:name Allows an alternative Realm to be specified (see [260]Glossary). The Kerberos 4 principal format is: userid[.instance[.instance]]@[realm] but can be omitted if it is the same as your username or SET LOGIN USERID value on the client system. AUTHENTICATE K5 INITIALIZE switches (all optional): /ADDRESSES:list-of-ip-addresses Specifies a list of IP addresses that should be placed in the Ticket Granting Ticket in addition to the local machine addresses. /FORWARDABLE Requests forwardable tickets. /KERBEROS4 Instructs Kermit to get Kerberos 4 tickets in addition to Kerberos 5 tickets. If Kerberos 5 tickets are not supported by the server, a mild warning is printed and Kerberos 4 tickets are requested. /LIFETIME:number Specifies the requested lifetime in minutes for the ticket. If no lifetime is specified, 600 minutes is used. If the lifetime is greater than the maximum supported by the ticket granting service, the resulting lifetime is shortened. /NO-ADDRESSES Instructs Kermit to not include a list of local IP addresses in the ticket retrieved from the KDC. /NO-KERBEROS4 Instructs Kermit to not attempt to retrieve Kerberos 4 credentials. /NOT-FORWARDABLE Requests non-forwardable tickets. /NOT-PROXIABLE Requests non-proxiable tickets. /PASSWORD:string Allows the inclusion of a password in a script. If no password is specified you are prompted for one. The password switch is provided for use by automated scripts. However, we strongly recommend that it not be used because clear-text passwords can be easily compromised. See Chapter 19 of [261]Using C-Kermit. /POSTDATE:date-time Requests a postdated ticket, valid starting at date-time. Postdated tickets are issued with the invalid flag set, and need to be fed back to the KDC before use with the /VALIDATE switch. See [262]Section 1.6 of the [263]C-Kermit 7.0 Update Notes for acceptable date-time formats. /PROXIABLE Requests proxiable tickets. /REALM:string Allows an alternative realm to be specified. /RENEW Requests renewal of a renewable Ticket Granting Ticket. Note that an expired ticket cannot be renewed even if it is within its renewable lifetime. /RENEWABLE:number Requests renewable tickets, with a total lifetime of number minutes. /SERVICE:string Allows a service other than the ticket granting service to be specified. /VALIDATE Requests that the Ticket Granting Ticket in the cache (with the invalid flag set) be passed to the KDC for validation. If the ticket is within its requested time range, the cache is replaced with the validated ticket. The Kerberos 5 principal format is: userid[/instance][@realm] and can be omitted if it is the same principal as stored in the current ticket cache at the time Kermit started; or the current username if a ticket cache did not exist. Note: Kerberos 5 always attempts to retrieve a Ticket Granting Ticket (TGT) using the preauthenticated TGT request. AUTHORIZE K5 LIST-CREDENTIALS [ switches ] Shows start time, expiration time, service or principal name, plus the following additional information depending the switches: /ADDRESSES Displays the hostnames and/or IP addresses embedded within the tickets. /ENCRYPTION Displays the encryption used by each ticket (if applicable): o DES-CBC-CRC o DES-CBC-MD4 o DES-CBC-MD5 o DES-CBC-RAW o DES-HMAC-SHA1 o DES3-CBC-RAW o DES3-CBC-SHA o DES3-HMAC-SHA1 /FLAGS provides the following information (if applicable) for each ticket: o F - Ticket is Forwardable o f - Ticket was Forwarded o P - Ticket is Proxiable o p - Ticket is a Proxy o D - Ticket may be Postdated o d - Ticket has been Postdated o i - Ticket is Invalid o R - Ticket is Renewable o I - Ticket is the Initial Ticket o H - Ticket has been authenticated by Hardware o A - Ticket has been Pre-authenticated 3.2.4. Other Security-Related Commands [ [264]Top ] [ [265]Contents ] [ [266]Chapter Contents ] [ [267]Section Contents ] [ [268]Glossary ] SET TCP ADDRESS [ ip-address ] Specifies the IP address of the computer that C-Kermit is running on. Normally this is not necessary. The exceptions would be if the host is [269]multihomed (e.g. one host pointed to by many IP addresses, or one of many hosts pointed to by a "common" IP address) or has multiple physical network adapters, with a different address for each adapter, AND you want C-Kermit to either (a) accept an incoming TCP connection ("set host *") or (b) get a Kerberos ticket. SET TCP REVERSE-DNS-LOOKUP { ON, OFF } Specifies whether or not a Reverse DNS Lookup should be performed to determine the hostname assigned to the IP address used to connect to the host. For mutual authentication to succeed, the client and the server must agree on the name to be used for the server. It is common for servers to have more than one name. This is especially true for clusters of servers that provide the same function and are referenced by an alias. For example, www.foo.com might be an alias for three machines www-1.foo.com, www-2.foo.com, and www-3.foo.com. If the hosts are configured to use separate credentials for authentication it would be necessary to know which host is actually in use since "www.foo.com" is not equal to "www-1.foo.com". On the other hand, since DNS is not a secure service, using an additional lookup to verify the name associated with a particular IP address increases the susceptibility that the authentication may be forged by an attacker. For the highest level of security, Reverse DNS Lookups should be turned OFF. [ [270]C-Kermit ] [ [271]C-Kermit 8.0 ] [ [272]Kermit 95 ] [ [273]Kermit Home ] ________________________________________________________________________ 3.3. Making Secure Connections [ [274]Top ] [ [275]Contents ] [ [276]Chapter Contents ] [ [277]Glossary ] SECTION CONTENTS 3.3.1. [278]The SET HOST Command 3.3.2. [279]The TELNET Command 3.3.3. [280]The RLOGIN Command 3.3.4. [281]Making Secure FTP Connections 3.3.5. [282]Making Secure HTTP Connections 3.3.6. [283]Using Only SSL or TLS 3.3.7. [284]Using Kerberos 5 User-to-User Protocol TCP/IP connections established by Kermit are initiated either with the SET HOST command; a protocol-specific command such as TELNET or RLOGIN; or in the case of FTP and HTTP an OPEN command. 3.3.1. The SET HOST Command [ [285]Top ] [ [286]Contents ] [ [287]Chapter Contents ] [ [288]Section Contents ] [ [289]Glossary ] When using the SET HOST command to establish a secure connection, several switches are available between SET HOST and the hostname, plus a protocol switch at the end: SET HOST [ switches ] hostname-or-address [ service ] [ protocol-switch ] Establishes a connection to the specified network host on the currently selected network type. For TCP/IP connections, the default service is TELNET and the default protocol is TELNET. Not all protocols have a default service name. The following SET HOST switches are useful with secure connections: /CONNECT Tells Kermit to enter CONNECT (terminal) mode automatically if the connection is successful. /SERVER Tells Kermit to enter server mode automatically if the connection is successful. /USERID:[name] This switch is equivalent to SET LOGIN USERID or SET TELNET ENVIRONMENT USER . If a string is given, it sent to host during Telnet negotiations; if this switch is given but the string is omitted, no user ID is sent to the host. If this switch is not given, your current USERID value, \v(userid), is sent. When a userid is sent to the host it is a request to login as the specified user. /PASSWORD:[string] This switch is equivalent to SET LOGIN PASSWORD. If a string is given, it is treated as the password to be used (if required) by any Telnet Authentication protocol (Kerberos Ticket retrieval, Secure Remote Password, or X.509 certificate private key decryption.) If no password switch is specified a prompt is issued to request the password if one is required for the negotiated authentication method. The SET HOST protocol-switches used with secure connections are: /RLOGIN Use Rlogin protocol even if this is not an Rlogin port. /TELNET Send initial Telnet negotiations even if this is not a Telnet port. /K4LOGIN Use Kerberos IV klogin protocol even if this is not a klogin port. /EK4LOGIN Use Kerberos IV Encrypted login protocol even if this is not an eklogin port. /K5LOGIN Use Kerberos V klogin protocol even if this is not a klogin port. /EK5LOGIN Use Kerberos V Encrypted login protocol even if this is not an eklogin port. /K5USER2USER Use Kerberos V User to User protocol. /SSL Perform SSL negotiations. /SSL-TELNET Perform SSL negotiations and if successful start Telnet negotiations. /TLS Perform TLS negotiations. /TLS-TELNET Perform TLS negotiations and if successful start Telnet negotiations. 3.3.2. The TELNET Command [ [290]Top ] [ [291]Contents ] [ [292]Chapter Contents ] [ [293]Section Contents ] [ [294]Glossary ] The TELNET command combines a number of commands related to secure telnet connections into a single interface. TELNET /AUTH:type /ENCRYPT:type /USERID:[name] /PASSWORD:[string] host port The TELNET command is a shortcut for making interactive terminal connections on a TCP/IP network using Telnet protocol. When used for secure connections, Kermit's TELNET command is the equivalent of: SET TELOPT AUTH ... SET TELNET AUTH TYPE ... SET TELOPT ENCRYPT ... SET TELNET ENCRYPT TYPE ... SET LOGIN USERID ... SET LOGIN PASSWORD ... SET HOST /CONNECT host port /TELNET The optional TELNET command switches are: /AUTH:type Equivalent to SET TELNET AUTH TYPE type and SET TELOPT AUTH REQUIRED with the following exceptions. If the type is AUTO, then SET TELOPT AUTH REQUESTED is executed and if the type is NONE, then SET TELOPT AUTH REFUSED is executed. If START_TLS is negotiated REQUIRED becomes REQUESTED. /ENCRYPT:type Equivalent to SET TELNET ENCRYPT TYPE type and SET TELOPT ENCRYPT REQUIRED REQUIRED with the following exceptions. If the type is AUTO then SET TELOPT AUTH REQUESTED REQUESTED is executed and if the type is NONE then SET TELOPT ENCRYPT REFUSED REFUSED is executed. If START_TLS is negotiated REQUIRED becomes REFUSED. /USERID:[name] Equivalent to SET LOGIN USERID name or SET TELNET ENVIRONMENT USER name. If a string is given, it sent to host during Telnet negotiations; if this switch is given but the string is omitted, no user ID is sent to the host. If this switch is not given, your current USERID value, \v(userid), is sent. When a userid is sent to the host it is a request to login as the specified user. /PASSWORD:[string] This switch is equivalent to SET LOGIN PASSWORD. If a string is given, it is treated as the password to be used (if required) by any Telnet Authentication protocol (Kerberos Ticket retrieval, Secure Remote Password, or X.509 certificate private key decryption.) If no password switch is specified a prompt is issued to request the password if one is required for the negotiated authentication method. 3.3.3. The RLOGIN Command [ [295]Top ] [ [296]Contents ] [ [297]Chapter Contents ] [ [298]Section Contents ] [ [299]Glossary ] The RLOGIN (Remote Login) protocol is not as flexible as the Telnet protocol and supports no option mechanism. Authentication and privacy are not part of the RLOGIN protocol. When we refer to authenticated and encrypted RLOGIN we are really referring to one of four other protocols derived from RLOGIN: Kerberos 4 Remote Login (K4LOGIN); Kerberos 4 Encrypted Remote Login (EK4LOGIN); Kerberos 5 Remote Login (K5LOGIN); and Kerberos 5 Encrypted Remote Login (EK5LOGIN). RLOGIN /ENCRYPT /KERBEROS4 /KERBEROS5 hostname username The RLOGIN command is a shortcut for making interactive connections. It is the equivalent of specifying: SET LOGIN USERID ... SET HOST /CONNECT hostname service [ protocol-switch ] where the combinations of /ENCRYPT /KERBEROS4 /KERBEROS5 result in the following protocol-switches: /KERBEROS4 means service klogin and protocol k4login /KERBEROS4 /ENCRYPT means service eklogin and protocol ek4login /KERBEROS5 means service klogin and protocol k5login /KERBEROS5 /ENCRYPT means service eklogin and protocol ek5login 3.3.4. Making Secure FTP Connections [ [300]Top ] [ [301]Contents ] [ [302]Chapter Contents ] [ [303]Section Contents ] [ [304]Glossary ] By default Kermit tries to negotiate a secure authentication method and to obtain private command and data channels. Therefore, all that is normally required to establish a secure FTP session is to issue the FTP OPEN command. If the server to which you are connecting supports a common security mechanism, it is used to secure the session. For example, to establish a secure FTP connection using SRP the following commands could be executed: SET FTP AUTHTYPE SRP SET FTP AUTOAUTHENTICATE ON ; default setting SET FTP AUTOENCRYPTION ON ; default setting SET FTP AUTOLOGIN ON ; default setting SET FTP SRP CIPHER DES_ECB ; default setting SET FTP SRP HASH SHA1 ; default setting SET FTP COMMAND-PROTECTION-LEVEL PRIVATE ; default setting SET FTP DATA-PROTECTION-LEVEL PRIVATE ; default setting FTP OPEN host /USER:username /PASSWORD:password If the /USER and/or /PASSWORD switches are omitted, the user is prompted for the required fields. For example, to establish a secure FTP connection using GSSAPI-Kerberos 5 the following commands could be executed: SET AUTH KERBEROS5 REALM MY.REALM SET AUTH KERBEROS5 PRINCIPAL my-principal AUTH KERBEROS5 INIT SET FTP AUTHTYPE GSSAPI-KRB5 SET FTP AUTOAUTHENTICATE ON ; default setting SET FTP AUTOENCRYPTION ON ; default setting SET FTP AUTOLOGIN ON ; default setting SET FTP COMMAND-PROTECTION-LEVEL PRIVATE ; default setting SET FTP DATA-PROTECTION-LEVEL PRIVATE ; default setting FTP OPEN host /USER:username If the /USER switch is omitted, the user is prompted for the name to login as after authentication is performed. Here is an example using TLS to secure the FTP session for an anonymous user: SET AUTH TLS VERIFY-FILE ca-cert.pem SET FTP AUTHTYPE TLS SET FTP AUTOAUTHENTICATE ON ; default setting SET FTP AUTOENCRYPTION ON ; default setting SET FTP AUTOLOGIN ON ; default setting SET FTP COMMAND-PROTECTION-LEVEL PRIVATE ; default setting SET FTP DATA-PROTECTION-LEVEL PRIVATE ; default setting FTP OPEN host /ANONYMOUS Here is an example using FTP through an SSL Proxy Server: SET AUTH SSL VERIFY-FILE ca-cert.pem SET FTP AUTOLOGIN ON ; default setting SET FTP COMMAND-PROTECTION-LEVEL PRIVATE ; default setting SET FTP DATA-PROTECTION-LEVEL PRIVATE ; default setting FTP OPEN /SSL host /USER:username /PASSWORD:password If the /USER and/or /PASSWORD switches are omitted, the user is prompted for the required fields. 3.3.5. Making Secure HTTP Connections [ [305]Top ] [ [306]Contents ] [ [307]Chapter Contents ] [ [308]Section Contents ] [ [309]Glossary ] Here is an example of a secure GET: SET AUTH TLS VERIFY-FILE ca-cert.pem HTTP OPEN host HTTPS HTTP /USER:username /PASSWORD:password GET index.html index.html HTTP CLOSE 3.3.6. Using Only SSL or TLS [ [310]Top ] [ [311]Contents ] [ [312]Chapter Contents ] [ [313]Section Contents ] [ [314]Glossary ] Secure Sockets Layer (SSL) and Transport Layer Security (TLS) protocols were designed to secure e-commerce transactions (HTTP) over the Internet. Their use as a tunnel protocol is becoming widespread as a means for securing other protocols such as FTP, IMAP, POP3, LDAP, NNTP, and even insecure versions of Telnet (this is frequently done with STunnel: [315]http://www.stunnel.org/.) Kermit provides the ability to establish SSL and TLS connections to transfer data, script HTTP sessions, or use Telnet protocol without the START_TLS option. Kermit provides four protocol-switches for establishing SSL or TLS connections: /SSL, /TLS, /SSL-TELNET, and /TLS-TELNET. Unlike other protocols such as TELNET and RLOGIN there are no standard services (IP ports) assigned to these protocols. Use of these protocols assumes prior knowledge of the ports to connect to on the remote host. There are also no shortcut commands for use with these protocols. Use the SET HOST command as described above when making connections. The [316]SET AUTHENTICATION { SSL, TLS }... commands are used to configure the [317]certificates and authorities, and verification options used during connection establishment. [ [318]STunnel Case Study ] 3.3.7. Using Kerberos 5 User-to-User Protocol [ [319]Top ] [ [320]Contents ] [ [321]Chapter Contents ] [ [322]Section Contents ] [ [323]Glossary ] The Kerberos 5 authentication implemented in the Telnet protocol is a client to server authentication protocol. It requires that the parties to the authentication be an end user principal and a service principal. The Kerberos 5 User to User protocol is specificly designed to allow two end user principals to authenticate one another. The shared secret generated during the authentication is then used to ensure the privacy of the data transmitted on the connection. There is no shortcut command provided for Kerberos 5 User to User protocol; nor is there a default service. To establish a connection between two Kermit processes using Kerberos 5 User to User protocol: * Each user must have retrieved a valid Kerberos 5 TGT. * One user must issue a SET HOST * port /K5USER2USER command. * One user must issue a SET HOST hostname port /K5USER2USER command. [ [324]C-Kermit ] [ [325]C-Kermit 8.0 ] [ [326]Kermit 95 ] [ [327]Kermit Home ] ______________________________________________________________________ 3.4. Using Secure Connections [ [328]Top ] [ [329]Contents ] [ [330]Chapter Contents ] [ [331]Glossary ] Once you have a secure connection, you can use it just like a regular (insecure one). Telnet sessions are Telnet sessions; FTP is FTP. However, encryption and the subsequent decryption of a data stream can result in 10% to 60% reduction in file transfer performance depending on the encryption algorithm. Encrypted data streams are uncompressible, thus reducing throughput on PPP or SLIP connections. When OpenSSL is built with support for ZLIB compression and compressed SSL/TLS connections can be negotiated, the degradation in file transfer performance can be reduced. In Kermit 95, the authentication type and encryption levels are displayed in the terminal-screen status Line as follows: K4 Kerberos IV K5 Kerberos V NTLM NT LAN Manager SRP Secure Remote Password pp No encryption Ep Encryption to host, plaintext from host pD Plaintext to host, encryption from host ED Encryption both directions SSL Secure Sockets Layer (both directions) TLS Transport Layer Security (both directions) Encrypted sessions become unreadable if even one bit of data is inserted into or deleted from the data stream. One damaged bit results in nine damaged bytes but subsequent bytes remain readable. But since TCP/IP is a reliable transport by definition, none of this should occur. Windows login names are not case-sensitive. However, Unix login names are. If the Unix login name is "fred" but Windows was logged in using the name "Fred", authentication appears to succeed but telnetd closes the connection after Telnet negotiations are complete. There are several solutions to this problem: * Make sure the Windows login name is case identical to the Unix login name. (If Windows has recorded the login in the registry as "Fred" it won't matter if you login to Windows using "fred". The only way to correct this problem is to edit the Registry.) * Use the SET LOGIN USERID name command to set the proper login name before connecting to the telnet server. * Use the SET AUTHENTICATION { KERBEROS4, KERBEROS5 } PRINCIPAL name command to set the proper principal name before connecting to the telnet server. * Specify the remote username in the principal of your AUTHENTICATE Kxxx INITIALIZE command. Kermit adjusts the case of the name if and only if a case insensitive comparison of the SET LOGIN USERID name and the name in the authentication ticket shows no differences. [ [332]C-Kermit ] [ [333]C-Kermit 8.0 ] [ [334]Kermit 95 ] [ [335]Kermit Home ] ________________________________________________________________________ 4. INSTALLATION AND CONFIGURATION [ [336]Top ] [ [337]Contents ] [ [338]Glossary ] [ [339]Appendices ] [ [340]Previous ] This chapter is intended for those who are building secure Kermit programs from source code and/or installing secure versions of Kermit for use within their organization. It presumes that you've read all the previous chapters. CHAPTER CONTENTS 4.1. [341]Security in Kermit 95 4.2. [342]Security in C-Kermit 4.1. Security in Kermit 95 Kermit 95 comes precompiled with support for Kerberos 4, Kerberos 5, Secure Remote Password (SRP), NT Lan Manager (NTLM) authentication, OpenSSL's SSLv3 and TLSv1, and SSH v1 and v2. SECTION CONTENTS 4.1.1. [343]Kerberos 4.1.2. [344]SRP 4.1.3. [345]NTLM 4.1.4. [346]OpenSSL 4.1.5. [347]SSH 4.1.6. [348]Firewalls 4.1.7. [349]Adding Other Security Methods to Kermit 95 4.1.1. Kerberos in Kermit 95 [ [350]Top ] [ [351]Contents ] [ [352]Chapter Contents ] [ [353]Section Contents ] [ [354]Glossary ] Kermit 95 supports Kerberos Telnet Authentication, Kerberos Rlogin, Kerberos FTP, and Kerberos SSL/TLS (K5 only) when any of the following Kerberos IV or Kerberos V implementations are installed on a Windows 95 or Windows NT workstation: MIT Kerberos for Microsoft Operating Systems Release 2.1.1 Supports Kerberos 4 and Kerberos 5 version 1.2.x: [355]http://web.mit.edu/kerberos/www/ Naval Research Laboratories Supports Kerberos 5: [356]ftp://ftp.cmf.nrl.navy.mil/pub/kerberos5/README When Kerberos IV and/or Kerberos V are installed and the DLLs are located in the PATH, Kermit 95 attempts to negotiate authentication with the host if the host is Kerberized and if you have not instructed Kermit 95 to do otherwise. In addition, if the appropriate encryption patch (obtained from the Kermit Project) is installed, two-way encryption is also negotiated and used if authentication was negotiated. The encryption patch is available WITH EXPORT RESTRICTIONS at: [357]http://www.kermit-project.org/noexport.html Due to the length of the shared secret negotiated by Kerberos 4 only 56-bit DES encryption can be used. Per-PC configuration files may or may not be necessary at your installation. If your site's DNS servers supply Kerberos realm information, no configuration files are needed and you can skip to [358]Section 4.1.2. 4.1.1.1. Kerberos IV Configuration Files for K95 Kerberos IV uses three configuration files in the \WINDOWS directory: LEASH.INI (user settings), KRB.CON and KRBREALM.CON. KRB.CON and KRBREALM.CON are used by Kerberos IV to map your host's domain name to a realm and then to determine the name of the Kerberos server for that realm. As distributed from MIT, these files are set up for MIT's realm, domain, and host information, so if you are not at MIT you'll need to substitute the information for your own site; for example: KRB.CON: CC.COLUMBIA.EDU CC.COLUMBIA.EDU kerberos.cc.columbia.edu KERMIT.COLUMBIA.EDU kerberos.cc.columbia.edu COLUMBIA.EDU kerberos.cc.columbia.edu .KERBEROS.OPTION. dns The first line is the default Kerberos IV realm to be used. The subsequent lines list realms and the hostnames to be used to contact the KDC for that realm. The last line is an indicator that DNS can be used to map Realms to KDCs and host names to Realms. KRBREALM.CON: .CC.COLUMBIA.EDU CC.COLUMBIA.EDU CC.COLUMBIA.EDU CC.COLUMBIA.EDU .COLUMBIA.EDU CC.COLUMBIA.EDU COLUMBIA.EDU CC.COLUMBIA.EDU .KERMIT.COLUMBIA.EDU CC.COLUMBIA.EDU KERMIT.COLUMBIA.EDU CC.COLUMBIA.EDU Each line specifies either a domain name prefaced with a "." or a host name and the Kerberos IV realm to which it belongs. 4.1.1.2. The Kerberos V Configuration File for K95 Kerberos V uses a single configuration file, KRB5.CONF (KRB5.INI on Windows). This file must be customized for the domains, realms, and hosts used in your network environment. For example: [libdefaults] default_realm = CC.COLUMBIA.EDU default_tkt_enctypes = des-cbc-crc default_tgs_enctypes = des-cbc-crc ticket_lifetime = 600 dns_fallback = true [domain_realm] .cc.columbia.edu = CC.COLUMBIA.EDU cc.columbia.edu = CC.COLUMBIA.EDU .columbia.edu = CC.COLUMBIA.EDU columbia.edu = CC.COLUMBIA.EDU [realms] CC.COLUMBIA.EDU = { kdc = kerberos.columbia.edu:88 admin_server = kerberos.columbia.edu:749 default_domain = cc.columbia.edu supported_enctypes = des-cbc-crc:normal des-cbc-crc:v4 supported_keytypes = des:normal des-cbc-crc:v4 } 4.1.2. Secure Remote Password protocol in Kermit 95 [ [359]Top ] [ [360]Contents ] [ [361]Chapter Contents ] [ [362]Section Contents ] [ [363]Glossary ] Kermit 95 supports Telnet Authentication via Secure Remote Password protocol without any additional software. In addition, if the appropriate encryption patch (obtained from the Kermit Project) is installed, two-way encryption is also negotiated and used if authentication was negotiated. The encryption patch is available WITH EXPORT RESTRICTIONS at: [364]http://www.kermit-project.org/noexport.html Kermit 95 contains support for authenticating incoming connections using SRP. Unfortunately, there are no Windows based tools for creating the SRP password file. However, once a password and config file are created on Unix they can be copied to Windows. On Windows 9x the tpasswd and tpasswd.conf files are stored in the C:\WINDOWS directory. On NT they are stored in %windir%\SYSTEM32\DRIVERS\ETC. 4.1.3. NT LAN Manager Authentication in Kermit 95 [ [365]Top ] [ [366]Contents ] [ [367]Chapter Contents ] [ [368]Section Contents ] [ [369]Glossary ] NTLM authentication is a feature of Windows 95/98, NT, and Windows 2000. It is used to authenticate Windows clients to Windows services. Telnet Auth NTLM is implemented in the Microsoft Telnet Daemon that ships with NT Services for Unix and with Windows 2000. Windows 95/98 only contains support for the client whereas NT contains support for both client and server. Kermit 95 can authenticate incoming connections with NTLM when it is executing on NT. 4.1.4. OpenSSL support for SSLv3 and TLSv1 in Kermit 95 [ [370]Top ] [ [371]Contents ] [ [372]Chapter Contents ] [ [373]Section Contents ] [ [374]Glossary ] Kermit 95 supports SSL/TLS security via OpenSSL when the encryption patch (obtained from the Kermit Project) is installed. The encryption patch is available WITH EXPORT RESTRICTIONS at: [375]http://www.kermit-project.org/noexport.html On non-Unix platforms OpenSSL does not define default locations for certificates and revocation lists therefore the appropriate SET AUTH { SSL, TLS } commands must be given (e.g. included in the K95CUSTOM.INI or IKSD.KSC file) before certificate verification to be performed. As of Kermit 95 version 2.00 the default locations are provided as follows: * SET AUTH { SSL, TLS } VERIFY-DIR \v(exedir)certs * SET AUTH { SSL, TLS } VERIFY-FILE \v(exedir)ca_certs.pem * SET AUTH { SSL, TLS } CRL-DIR \v(exedir)crls * SET AUTH { SSL, TLS } CRL-FILE \v(exedir)ca_crls.pem Due to patent licensing restrictions on the IDEA algorithm within the United States, all binaries that the Kermit Project distributes to provide SSL/TLS support for Kermit 95 do not contain IDEA ciphers. See [376]Appendix III if you wish to provide server-side support for authentication of clients using public key certificates. 4.1.5. SSH v1 and v2 in Kermit 95 [ [377]Top ] [ [378]Contents ] [ [379]Chapter Contents ] [ [380]Section Contents ] [ [381]Glossary ] (To be filled in...) 4.1.6. Firewalls [ [382]Top ] [ [383]Contents ] [ [384]Chapter Contents ] [ [385]Section Contents ] [ [386]Glossary ] The Windows versions of Kermit 95 do not support SOCKS; the OS/2 version has built-in support for SOCKS4. NEC distributes a SOCKS5 Winsock shim for Windows 9x/NT at: [387]ftp://ftp.nec.co.jp/pub/packages/sotools/ 4.1.7. Adding Other Security Methods to Kermit 95 [ [388]Top ] [ [389]Contents ] [ [390]Chapter Contents ] [ [391]Section Contents ] [ [392]Glossary ] Kermit 95 includes a DLL interface for adding new security methods. The DLL can be loaded with the SET NETWORK TYPE command: SET NETWORK TYPE DLL dll-file The connection is made with a SET HOST command: SET HOST command-line where the command-line is passed to the DLL after the normal Kermit quoting rules are applied. A C language skeleton for the DLL is available here: [393]http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/k95dll_c.txt ________________________________________________________________________ 4.2. Security in C-Kermit [ [394]Top ] [ [395]Contents ] [ [396]Chapter Contents ] [ [397]Glossary ] SECTION CONTENTS 4.2.1. [398]Kerberos 4.2.2. [399]SRP 4.2.3. [400]SSL/TLS 4.2.4. [401]Shadow Passwords 4.2.5. [402]PAM 4.2.6. [403]Using External Security Methods with C-Kermit C-Kermit 8.0 can be compiled with support for Kerberos 4, Kerberos 5, Secure Remote Password, and OpenSSL's SSLv3 and TLSv1. As of this writing the following combinations of platforms and security protocols are provided in the Makefile distributed with C-Kermit: * aix41+krb5+krb4 * aix43gcc+krb5+krb4 * aix43gcc+krb5+krb4+openssl * irix6x+krb5 * irix65+krb5 * linux+krb5 * linux+krb5+krb4 * linux+srp+gmp * linux+srp+gmp+no-des * linux+srp+gmp-export * linux+srp+gmp+pam * linux+srp * linux+srp+pam * linux+shadow+pam * linux+openssl * linux+openssl+shadow * linux+openssl+zlib+shadow+pam * linux+srp+openssl * linux+krb5+krb4+srp * linux+krb5+krb4+srp+openssl * linux+krb5+krb4+openssl * linux+krb5+krb4+openssl+shadow * linux+krb5+krb4+openssl+zlib+shadow * linux+krb5+krb4+srp-export * linux+krb5+krb4+srp+pam * linux+krb5+krb4+srp+openssl+pam-debug * linux+krb5+krb4+srp+openssl+pam * linux+krb5+krb4+srp+openssl+zlib+pam * linux+krb5+openssl+zlib+shadow+pam * redhat71 * redhat71+srp * solaris2x+krb4 * solaris2xg+krb4 * solaris2xg+openssl+zlib+pam+shadow * solaris2xg+openssl+pam+shadow * solaris2xg+krb5+krb4+openssl+shadow * solaris25+krb4 * solaris25g+krb4 * solaris25g+krb5+krb4+openssl+shadow * solaris26g+openssl * solaris8g+openssl+zlib+pam+shadow * solaris8g+krb4 * sunos41gcc+krb4 * sunos41gcc+openssl * sunos41gcc+krb4+openssl * sunos41gcc+krb4+openssl+zlib * sunos41gcc+krb4+srp+openssl+zlib * sunos41gcc+srp+openssl+zlib * uw7ssl 4.2.1. Kerberos in C-Kermit 8.0 [ [404]Top ] [ [405]Contents ] [ [406]Chapter Contents ] [ [407]Section Contents ] [ [408]Glossary ] Kerberos IV and Kerberos V support is available for Unix versions of C-Kermit 8.0. Kerberos support in C-Kermit is provided for both outgoing and incoming connections (SET HOST /SERVER * port /TELNET or the [409]Internet Kermit Service). Kerberized C-Kermit binaries are not available due to export restrictions (see [410]Section 2); you must build your own binary from a combination of Columbia source code and Kerberos libraries from other sources. 1. Retrieve a Kerberos 5 1.2.2 or later source code kit from the appropriate site: [411]http://web.mit.edu/kerberos/www/ [412]http://web.mit.edu/network/kerberos-form.html 2. Choose a Kerberos 4 installation (from MIT) and retrieve a source code kit from the appropriate site: [413]http://web.mit.edu/kerberos/www/ [414]http://web.mit.edu/network/kerberos-form.html 3. Build and install Kerberos on your system according to the instructions that come with the Kerberos distribution you have chosen. 4. Add a new entry to the C-Kermit makefile for your platform that uses "krbmit" as the build target and adds the following to CFLAGS: -DCK_AUTHENTICATION -DCK_KERBEROS For Kerberos 4 include: -DKRB4 $(K4INC) For Kerberos 5 include: -DKRB5 $(K5INC) For Kerberos 5 with Kerberos 4 compatibility mode: -DKRB5 -DKRB524 -DKRB4 $(K5INC) If you desire DES and 3DES encryption include: -DCK_ENCRYPTION -DCK_DES Add the appropriate libraries to LIBS. For Kerberos 4 include: $(K4LIB) -lkrb For Kerberos 5 include: $(K5LIB) -lgssapi_krb5 -lkrb5 -lcom_err -lk5crypto For Kerberos 4 compatibility mode with Kerberos 5 include: $(K5LIB) -ldes425 -lkrb4 -lgssapi_krb5 -lkrb5 -lcom_err -lk5crypto The makefile defines the path to the Kerberos header files using the variables K4INC or K5INC: -I/usr/kerberos/include The location of the Kerberos libraries is specified using the variables K4LIB or K5LIB: -L/usr/kerberos/lib The Kerberos header files and libraries are often installed in host specific locations. The values of the K4INC, K5INC, K4LIB, and K5LIB variables can be altered by: + Editing the makefile + Defining new values on the make command line + Exporting the variables to the system environment and specifying the -e on the make command line. Use the "linux+krb5", "linux+krb5+krb4", and "sunos41gcc+krb4" makefile entries as models. Note that the select() version of the CONNECT-command module (ckucns.c) must be used rather than the older fork() based (ckucon.c) version. When C-Kermit 8.0 is built with Kerberos support and installed as an [415]Internet Kermit Service Daemon (IKSD), Kerberos is offered for authenticating incoming connections if there is a valid keytab file providing local access to the key necessary for decrypting messages encoded in the server's key. Note: Due to conflicts between the internal DES implementations used by MIT Kerberos 4 (not the Kerberos 4 compatibility mode provided by Kerberos 5) and OpenSSL, C-Kermit cannot be built to support Kerberos 4 FTP authentication when both OpenSSL and Kerberos 4 are used in combination. 4.2.2. Secure Remote Password protocol in C-Kermit [ [416]Top ] [ [417]Contents ] [ [418]Chapter Contents ] [ [419]Section Contents ] [ [420]Glossary ] Secure Remote Password (SRP) support is available for Unix versions of C-Kermit 8.0. SRP support in C-Kermit is provided for both outgoing and incoming connections (SET HOST /SERVER * port /TELNET or the Internet Kermit Service). SRP C-Kermit binaries are not available due to export restrictions (see [421]Section 2); you must build your own binary from a combination of Columbia source code and SRP libraries from other sources. 1. Retrieve the SRP 1.7.4 source code kit from: [422]http://srp.stanford.edu/srp/ 2. There are several different methods for configuring the build process of SRP. Two methods are supported for use with C-Kermit. The recommended way is to build SRP using OpenSSL to provide the required big number math and cryptographic functionality. DES/3DES functionality is built into OpenSSL. The second method is to build SRP with the GNU MP library for big number math and use SRP's Krypto library for the cryptographic functionality. If Regardless of which method you decide to use, be sure to read the installation instructions before installing because SRP replaces many standard Unix system files and failure to follow the procedures may leave you locked out of your system. 3. Add a new entry to the C-Kermit makefile for your platform that: uses "srpmit" as the build target and adds the following CFLAGS: -DCK_AUTHENTICATION -DCK_SRP $(SRPINC) If you built SRP with OpenSSL add: $(SSLINC) If you desire telnet encryption include: -DCK_ENCRYPTION For CAST encryption add: -DCK_CAST For DES and 3DES encryption add: -DCK_DES -DLIBDES Add the appropriate libraries to LIBS. If you built SRP using OpenSSL: $(SRPLIB) -lsrp -lkrypto $(SSLLIB) -lcrypto If you built SRP with GNU MP but without DES/3DES support use: $(SRPLIB) -lsrp -lgmp -lkrypto If you built SRP with GNU MP and Eric Young's DES library use: $(SRPLIB) -lsrp -lgmp -ldes -lkrypto The makefile defines the path to the SRP header files using the variable SRPINC: -I/usr/local/include The location of the Kerberos libraries is specified using the variable SRPLIB: -L/usr/local/lib The makefile defines the path to the OpenSSL header files using the variable SSLINC: -I/usr/local/ssl/include The location of the OpenSSL libraries is specified using the variable SSLLIB: -L/usr/local/ssl/lib The SRP and OpenSSL header files and libraries are often installed in host specific locations. The values of the SRPINC, SRPLIB, SSLINC, and SSLLIB variables can be altered by: + Editing the makefile + Defining new values on the make command line + Exporting the variables to the system environment and specifying the -e on the make command line. Use the "linux+srp" and "linux+krb5+krb4+srp" makefile entries as models. Note that the select() version of the CONNECT-command module (ckucns.c) must be used rather than the older fork() based (ckucon.c) version. When C-Kermit 8.0 is built with SRP support and installed as an [423]Internet Kermit Service Daemon (IKSD), SRP is offered for authenticating incoming connections. 4.2.3. OpenSSL support for SSLv3 and TLSv1 in C-Kermit 8.0. [ [424]Top ] [ [425]Contents ] [ [426]Chapter Contents ] [ [427]Section Contents ] [ [428]Glossary ] OpenSSL support is available for Unix versions of C-Kermit 8.0. SSLv3 and TLSv1 support in C-Kermit is provided for both outgoing and incoming connections (SET HOST /SERVER * port /TELNET or the [429]Internet Kermit Service). OpenSSL C-Kermit binaries are not available due to export restrictions (see [430]Section 2); you must build your own binary from a combination of Columbia source code and the OpenSSL libraries from other sources. 1. Retrieve the OpenSSL 0.9.6b source code kit from: [431]http://www.openssl.org/ 2. Build OpenSSL according to the installation instructions. Be aware that OpenSSL includes support for algorithms that are covered by patents or claimed as intellectual property in the United States (and perhaps some other countries.) Use of these algorithms without the proper licenses can make you liable to legal action. Be sure to read the entire README file before building and installing OpenSSL. OpenSSL has many features that can be selected when it is configured prior to compiling the libraries. One feature that's useful to C-Kermit is support for Anonymous-Diffie-Hellman (ADH) ciphers in SRP and Kerberos 5 Telnet Authentication. Note: If you are using a version of OpenSSL later than SNAPSHOT 20011201 you can build it with support for ZLIB compression and Kerberos 5 ciphers. However, OpenSSL releases prior to version 1.0 are not guaranteed to be backward compatible. C-Kermit 8.0 builds with any 0.9.6 version of OpenSSL. C-Kermit 8.0 might not build with future versions of OpenSSL without modification. 3. Add a new entry to the C-Kermit makefile for your platform that uses "krbmit" as the build target and adds the following to CFLAGS: -DCK_AUTHENTICATION -DCK_SSL $(SSLINC) To add support for ZLIB compression add the following to CFLAGS: -DZLIB Add the appropriate libraries to LIBS: $(SSLLIB) -lssl -lcrypto For ZLIB compression add to LIBS: -lzlib The makefile defines the path to the OpenSSL header files using the variable SSLINC: -I/usr/local/ssl/include The location of the OpenSSL libraries is specified using the variable SSLLIB: -L/usr/local/ssl/lib The OpenSSL header files and libraries are often installed in host specific locations. The values of the SSLINC and SSLLIB variables can be altered by: + editing the makefile + defining new values on the make command line + exporting the variables to the system environment and specifying the -e on the make command line. Use the "linux+openssl" and "linux+krb5+krb4+srp+openssl" makefile entries as models. Note that the select() version of the CONNECT-command module (ckucns.c) must be used rather than the older fork() based (ckucon.c) version. When C-Kermit 8.0 is installed as an Internet Kermit Service (IKSD), TLSv1 is offered for authenticating incoming connections via the Telnet START_TLS option. If you wish to provide support for authentication of clients using public key certificates you must provide two custom functions X509_to_user() and X509_userok. These functions provide the certificate to local userid mapping and user authorization functionality. Example functions that use the /UID field of the Certificate Subject name may be activated by specifying: make entry KFLAGS=-DX509_UID_TO_USER when compiling C-Kermit. If you with to use the Certificate Subject Alternate Name you can specify: make entry KFLAGS=-DX509_SUBJECT_ALT_NAME_TO_USER The X509_to_user() and X509_userok() functions are the last functions in the ck_ssl.c module. See [432]Appendix III. 4.2.4. Shadow Passwords in C-Kermit 8.0 [ [433]Top ] [ [434]Contents ] [ [435]Chapter Contents ] [ [436]Section Contents ] [ [437]Glossary ] Shadow password files are used in many versions of Unix to provide a greater level of security for user passwords stored on the local disk. The standard Unix password file must be world readable so processes can find out the user's shell, home directory, and other permissions. By moving the passwords into a separate file that only stores passwords, access to the file can be restricted to only those processes that are authorized to perform authentication. When C-Kermit 8.0 is used as the Internet Kermit Service on systems that are configured to use shadow passwords the following CFLAG must be added to the makefile entry: -DCK_SHADOW 4.2.5. Pluggable Authentication Module (PAM) Support in C-Kermit 8.0 [ [438]Top ] [ [439]Contents ] [ [440]Chapter Contents ] [ [441]Section Contents ] [ [442]Glossary ] PAM is implemented in many versions of Unix so system administrators can add new forms of authentication for interactive login (console, telnet, rlogin, ...) without requiring recompilation of each service. When C-Kermit 8.0 is used as the Internet Kermit Service on systems that are configured to use PAM the following CFLAG must be added to the makefile entry: -DCK_PAM and the following libraries may have to be included: -lpam -ldl The default PAM Service Name is "kermit". If you wish to use a different name specify: KFLAGS=-DPAM_SERVICE_NAME="service-name" when building C-Kermit. Before C-Kermit can be used with PAM, configuration information must be added for the specified PAM_SERVICE_NAME to either /etc/pam.conf or /etc/pam.d/ depending on the version of PAM your operating system has installed. A complete primer on PAM can (or once could be) be found at: [443]http://www.kernel.org/pub/linux/libs/pam/Linux-PAM-html/. 4.2.6. Using External Security Methods with C-Kermit [ [444]Top ] [ [445]Contents ] [ [446]Chapter Contents ] [ [447]Section Contents ] [ [448]Glossary ] Other protocols can be used to create secure connections that are not currently implemented in Kermit, such as Secure Shell (SSH). The fact that SSH is not integrated into Kermit software does not mean that Kermit cannot be used in conjunction with it. SSH provides for tunneling, which allows a localhost proxy to be configured to take insecure connections on the local machine and connect them via secure connections to remote hosts. Secure connection clients can be used as the communication channel in C-Kermit 7.0 and later and Kermit 95 1.1.16 and later via the PTY (Unix only) and PIPE commands. See [449]Section 2.7 of the [450]C-Kermit 7.0 Update Notes for details. Firewalls based on access lists, proxies, and SOCKS do not provide secure connections. However, they do restrict the ports that may be used to communicate between the Internet and the Intranet which makes it more difficult for someone to break into the Intranet from outside. They do not protect the network from internal attacks nor do they protect a connection, once made, from eavesdropping or hijacking. They may be used in conjunction with secure connection systems but should not be used as a replacement for them. C-Kermit can be built as a SOCKS client if you have a SOCKS library; otherwise you can run SOCKSified Telnet or Rlogin clients through C-Kermit with the PIPE command. See [451]C-Kermit Configuration Options document for details. [ [452]C-Kermit ] [ [453]C-Kermit 8.0 ] [ [454]Kermit 95 ] ________________________________________________________________________ APPENDIX I. WHERE TO FIND SECURE TELNET AND FTP SERVERS [ [455]Top ] [ [456]Contents ] [ [457]Glossary ] [ [458]Home ] CONTENTS I.1. [459]Telnet I.2. [460]FTP I.3. [461]Internet Kermit Service I.4. [462]HTTP I.5. [463]Securing Insecure Services with STunntl Contrary to widespread misconception, Telnet and FTP are not insecure protocols to be discarded. These protocols have been secured by the IETF through the addition of standard security methods: Kerberos, SSL/TLS, and SRP (see [464]REFERENCES) and continue to offer manifold advantages over their would-be replacements in terms of functionality, flexibility, and platform independence. If your operating system does not include secure remote access methods, secure third-party servers can often be found. I.1. Secure Telnet Servers [ [465]Top ] [ [466]Contents ] [ [467]Appendix Contents ] [ [468]Glossary ] Sun Solaris 8 and later Ships with a Kerberos 5 enabled Telnetd. Apple Mac OS X Ships with a Kerberos 5 enabled Telnetd. Cisco IOS The telnet server for Cisco routers, terminal servers, ... ships with Kerberos 5 support. SCO (Caldera) OSR5, Unixware 7, and Open UNIX 8 Ships with Kerberos 5 support. Z/OS V1R2.0 Communication Server for Server/390 IP Ships with Kerberos 5 support: [469]http://www-1.ibm.com/servers/eserver/zseries/zos/commserver/kerberos.htm l Debian and Red Hat Linux Recent versions ship with Kerberos 5 support. HP-UX 11 Ships with Kerberos 5 support. Compaq DCE for OpenVMS provides Kerberos 5 support. MIT Kerberos 5 1.2.3 The Kerberos 5 Telnet server is part of the standard Kerberos 5 distribution available from MIT. Kerberos 5 is unique among authentication methods in offering true single sign-on capability to the network via forwarded credentials. It also allows authentication to cross Kerberos realms; for example, between different organizations. The Kerberos 5 Telnet server is "downwards compatible" with the older Kerberos 4 protocol. The Kerberos 5 Telnet authentication protocol provides for strong mutual authentication of the client and server without requiring the client to possess prior knowledge of the server's credentials. During authentication a session key (DES, RC4, 3DES) is produced that is used with a negotiated encryption algorithm to give privacy protection to incoming and outgoing data. [470]http://web.mit.edu/kerberos/www/ Follow the links to "Getting Kerberos from MIT". Future versions of the MIT Kerberos 5 distribution will include support for SSL/TLS and X Windows System Data Forwarding. MIT Kerberos 4 The precursor to Kerberos 5. Kerberos 4 provides strong authentication without the single sign-on or cross-realm capabilities of Kerberos 5. The Kerberos 4 Telnet server is part of the Kerberos 4 distribution. The Kerberos 4 Telnet authentication protocol provides for strong mutual authentication of client and server without requiring prior knowledge by the client of the server's credentials. During authentication a session key (56-bit DES only) is produced for use with a negotiated encryption algorithm for privacy of incoming and outgoing data. [471]http://web.mit.edu/kerberos/www/ Follow the links to "Getting Kerberos from MIT". Secure Remote Password SRP is based on Zero Knowledge Identification algorithms by which the client and server prove their identities by exchanging data over a public channel. This data can't be used to determine the secrets involved nor can it be used to replicate the authentication sequence. Authentication of the server does not require the client to have prior knowledge of the server's credentials. During authentication a session key (320-bits) is produced for use with a negotiated encryption algorithm to provide privacy protection to incoming and outgoing data. As of the 1.7.1 release, the SRP Telnet client and server implement the START_TLS option as well as the X Windows Systems Data Forwarding option. This distribution can be built against MIT Kerberos 5 or MIT Kerberos 4 distribution to enable Kerberos authentication. The combination of START_TLS and AUTH (SRP and KRB5) provide for the strongest combination of private communication and password based mutual authentication. The SRP Telnet server is part of the SRP distribution: [472]http://www-cs-students.stanford.edu/~tjw/srp/ Follow the link to Download Software Transport Layer Security (X.509 certificates and Kerberos 5) TLSv1 (the successor to SSLv3 used in most Web browsers) provides strong encryption and optional authentication of the server and client using X.509 certificates or Kerberos 5. Authentication of the server via X.509 requires the client to have prior knowledge of the server's X.509 certificate or the certificates of the Certificate Authorities that signed the server's certificate. An open source distribution of TLSv1 is available from: [473]http://www.openssl.org/ Current development snapshots of OpenSSL are required for Kerberos 5 support. A Telnet server that implements the START_TLS option and X Windows System Data Forwarding is available from: [474]ftp://ftp.runestig.com/pub/starttls/start_tls-telnet.current.tar.gz ________________________________________________________________________ I.2. Secure FTP Servers [ [475]Top ] [ [476]Contents ] [ [477]Appendix Contents ] [ [478]Glossary ] MIT Kerberos 5 1.2.3 The Kerberos 5 FTP server is part of the standard Kerberos 5 distribution available from MIT. Kerberos 5 is unique among authentication methods in offering true single sign-on capability to the network via forwarded credentials. It also allows authentication to cross Kerberos realms; for example, between different organizations. The Kerberos 5 FTP server provides for strong authentication using either Kerberos 4 or GSSAPI-Kerberos 5. Both the command and data channels are encrypted and integrity protected. [479]http://web.mit.edu/kerberos/www/ Follow the links to "Getting Kerberos from MIT". Future versions of the MIT Kerberos 5 distribution will include support for SSL/TLS and X Windows System Data Forwarding. MIT Kerberos 4 The precursor to Kerberos 5. Kerberos 4 provides strong authentication without the single sign-on or cross-realm capabilities of Kerberos 5. The Kerberos 4 Telnet and FTP clients and servers are part of the Kerberos 4 distribution. The Kerberos 4 FTP server provides for strong authentication. Both the command and data channels are encrypted and integrity protected. [480]http://web.mit.edu/kerberos/www/ Follow the links to "Getting Kerberos from MIT". Secure Remote Password SRP is based on Zero Knowledge Identification algorithms by which the client and server prove their identities by exchanging data over a public channel. This data can't be used to determine the secrets involved nor can it be used to replicate the authentication sequence. Authentication of the server does not require the client to have prior knowledge of the server's credentials. During authentication a session key (320-bits) is produced for use with a negotiated encryption algorithm to provide privacy protection to incoming and outgoing data. The FTP server provides for strong authentication. Both the command and data channels are encrypted and integrity protected with a user selectable set of encryption algorithms (blowfish, cast-128, 3des, des) and hash algorithms (md5, sha-1). [481]http://www-cs-students.stanford.edu/~tjw/srp/ Follow the link to Download Software Transport Layer Security (X.509 certificates and Kerberos 5) TLSv1 (the successor to SSLv3 used in most Web browsers) provides strong encryption and optional authentication of the server and client using X.509 certificates or Kerberos 5. Authentication of the server via X.509 requires the client to have prior knowledge of the server's X.509 certificate or the certificates of the Certificate Authorities that signed the server's certificate. An open source distribution of TLSv1 is available from: [482]http://www.openssl.org/ Current development snapshots of OpenSSL are required for Kerberos 5 support. Two FTP servers that implement the SSL/TLS protocol for securing both the command and data channels are available from: [483]ftp://ftp.runestig.com/pub/ftp-tls/ [484]ftp://ftp.runestig.com/pub/ftpd-tls/ [485]ftp://ftp.runestig.com/pub/proftpd-tls/ ________________________________________________________________________ I.3. Secure Internet Kermit Service [ [486]Top ] [ [487]Contents ] [ [488]Appendix Contents ] [ [489]Glossary ] Available from Columbia University: * [490]User Documentation * [491]Administrator Documentation * (coming soon) Windows version... I.4. Secure HTTP Servers [ [492]Top ] [ [493]Contents ] [ [494]Appendix Contents ] [ [495]Glossary ] Most web servers provide support for SSL/TLS secured HTTP connections. I.5. Securing Insecure Services with STunnel [ [496]Top ] [ [497]Contents ] [ [498]Appendix Contents ] [ [499]Glossary ] It is also possible to wrap a nonsecure service such as Telnet or Sredird in [500]Stunnel, for use with Kermit's ability to negotiate non-secure protocols over SSL/TLS; [501]CLICK HERE for a case study. ________________________________________________________________________ APPENDIX II. MULTI-HOMED HOSTS, FIREWALLS, AND NETWORK ADDRESS TRANSLATION [ [502]Top ] [ [503]Contents ] [ [504]Glossary ] CONTENTS II.1. [505]Firewalls II.2. [506]Network Address Translation II.3. [507]Multi-Homed Hosts and Aliasing The Internet was originally designed for end-to-end communication between connected computers belonging to a single cloud. All computers were able to directly communicate with all the other computers attached to the network. In particular, if computer A could communicate with computer B then computer B could communicate with computer A. Unfortunately, this no longer true. Three factors changed this. First, the abuse of the Internet by hackers and virus/worm authors convinced organizations that wished to join the internet that it was not safe to do so without limiting their exposure. This resulted in the popular use of firewalls to restrict the types of communications that could flow across the Internet gateways. The second factor was the success of the world wide web and the use of client only computers that did not have permanent addresses. These computers (mostly DOS, Windows, and Macintosh) did not run services and were only used to communicate with a very small number of server computers that spoke HTTP. Connectivity to these machines only required one way communication: from the client to the server. The third factor was the explosion in the number of client devices that are connected to the Internet. When an individual or company wants to connect their computers to the Internet they need to be assigned IP addresses for their computers. However, most ISPs sell service based on the number of assigned IP addresses or, in the case of home networks, provide only a single address. To save money or simply two put all the kids' computers on the network at the same time, people started to experiment with network gateways that implemented Network Address Translation (NAT). The NAT would convert the IP addresses of multiple computers on the private side of the gateway to share a single address on the public side of the gateway. A computer that has been assigned an address that is being translated can establish and listen for connections with other computers on the private side of the network and can establish connections to computers on the public side of the network. However, the computers cannot receive connections established from computers on the pubic side of the network because the true address of the computer has been hidden. These factors complicate the use of many Internet protocols such as FTP and cause problems for authentication systems. In addition to these problems there are some other issues that must be taken into account. It is possible for a single computer to have multiple network adapter cards. This is often done to allow a computer to act as a gateway between two networks; to provide the computer with redundancy for critical services; or to allow the computer to maintain more than one identity (such as to provide web services for two different domains.) Computers with multiple network addresses are referred to as being "multi-homed". There are also potential problems caused when multiple computers are used to serve a single purpose. For instance, a web server for a large commercial operation probably does not have a single computer providing service to all of their customers. Instead they have a farm (or cluster) of computers. The one you actually are served by is determined randomly using a load-balancing algorithm. When you authenticate to one of these computers you do not want to authenticate to the individual name assigned to each computer but to the common name used to access any one of them. The technique used to allow multiple computers to respond to a single name is called "aliasing". II.1 Firewalls [ [508]Top ] [ [509]Contents ] [ [510]Appendix Contents ] [ [511]Glossary ] Firewalls are used to restrict the types of network packets that may cross a network boundary. Firewall products fall into four general categories: Port Filtering Firewalls Port Filtering firewalls are the simplist of the firewall techniques. Port filtering is performed by specifying an ordered set of ACCEPT and DENY rules for each combination of: + packet type + source address + source port + destination address + destination port + if packet type is TCP, whether a connection must exist or not This allows a firewall to be configured to only allow through the firewall packets that are meant for specific computers; or packets meant for specific services; or packets to/from specific hosts/networks. Port Filtering firewalls frequently cause problems for users of Kerberos authentication when they are not configured to allow UDP packets to be sent or received from the Key Distribution Center. Port Filtering firewalls are also a problem for the FTP protocol since the standard mode is for the FTP server to establish a data channel on a random port number to the FTP client when data is to be transferred. This port number is agreed to be sending the destination address and port value across the FTP command channel. Port Filtering firewalls need to be configured to allow connections from clients to reach the host ports necessary for each protocol that is used with Kermit: Port Protocol 21/tcp FTP 22/tcp SSH 23/tcp Telnet 80/tcp HTTP 88/udp Kerberos 5 authentication 443/tcp HTTP over TLS 750/udp Kerberos 4 authentication 990/tcp FTP over TLS 992/tcp Telnet over TLS 1649/tcp Internet Kermit Service (Kermit) The official list of "well-known" and "registered" port assignments is available from Internet Assigned Numbers Authority: [512]http://www.iana.org/assignments/port-numbers Content-Aware Firewalls Content-Aware Firewalls attempt to solve the problem with FTP and similar protocols that transmit addressing information as part of the protocol. These firewalls are aware of a specific set of internet protocols such as FTP. When the FTP client specifies the destination address and port to used by the server to establish the data channel, the firewall can watch and temporarily allow that connection to pass through the firewall. Unfortunately, Content Aware Firewalls cannot work with secure protocols since all of the data is being transmitted in encrypted form. Application Layer Gateways Application Layer Gateways are services that appear to be the actually service you wish to connect to. Instead of connecting directly to the telnet service on foo.bar.com you connect to the telnet service on the firewall and allow the firewall to establish an equivalent session with the telnet service on foo.bar.com. As with Content-Aware Firewalls this procedure simply does not work with secure connections. The Application Layer Gateway (ALG) will either not know the key to use to read the protected data; or the ALG will be able to decrypt all of the data and the end-to-end security of the connection know has a location where a man-in-the-middle attack can be targeted. Authenticated Firewall Traversal Protocols Authenticated Firewall Traversal Protocols simply allow a client process running on a computer to create connections that may cross the firewall once the client or service has been authenticated and authorized. These firewalls are quite flexible and work very well with secure connections. In fact, they enhance the security of the connection from the perspective of the network administrator. II.1.1 FTP Passive Mode [ [513]Top ] [ [514]Contents ] [ [515]Appendix Contents ] [ [516]Glossary ] FTP is one of the few well-known Internet services that requires the use of multiple connections. As described above, FTP originally required the server to establish the data connection to the client using a destination address and port provided by the client. This method of operation does not work with Port Filtering Firewalls. More recently, FTP was extended to support "passive mode". When passive mode is use the connections for the data channels are created in the reverse direction. Instead of the server establishing a connection to the client; the client establishes a second connection with server as the destination. This works just fine as long as the client is behind the firewall and the server is in public address space. If the server is behind a firewall then the traditional mode must be used. If both the client and server are each behind their own Port Filtering Firewalls then data channels cannot be established. This is supposed to be solved by the use of Content Aware Firewalls or Application Layer Gateways. However, was the command channel is encrypted the Firewall is unable to view the IP address information. In Kermit, the use of passive mode is controlled with the command: SET FTP PASSIVE-MODE { ON, OFF } The default is to use passive mode. II.1.2 Firewall Traversal via an HTTP Proxy [ [517]Top ] [ [518]Contents ] [ [519]Appendix Contents ] [ [520]Glossary ] The simplist form of firewall traversal is the HTTP CONNECT command. The CONNECT command was implemented to allow a public web server which usually resides on the boundary between the public and private networks to forward HTTP requests from clients on the private network to public web sites. In order to allow secure web connections to be established, the CONNECT command works by authenticating the client with a username/password and then establishing a tunnel to the desired host. Many web servers support the CONNECT command and it can be configured to allow outgoing connections to authenticated user to any TCP/IP hostname/port combination accessible to the web server. The limitations of HTTP CONNECT is that it can only be used for outgoing connections for protocols that are implemented using TCP/IP. Protocols such as Kerberos authentication that use UDP/IP cannot be tunneled using HTTP CONNECT. Kermit provides support for the use of HTTP CONNECT proxy services with the command: SET TCP HTTP-PROXY hostname/ip-address[:port] When a port is not specified the default port configured on the HTTP server is used. This is frequently port 443. When a hostname is specified, it is resolved using the DNS available to the web server. II.1.3 Firewall Traversal with SOCKS [ [521]Top ] [ [522]Contents ] [ [523]Appendix Contents ] [ [524]Glossary ] In the early 1990s as firewalls were becoming prevalent, David Koblas developed the SOCKS protocol for firewall traversal of TCP/IP. There are two popular versions of SOCKS currently in use. Version 4.2 provides support for client applications using TCP/IP to traverse firewalls. This functionality is similar to the support provided by HTTP CONNECT. However, there is one distinction. A client using SOCKS is aware of the public source IP address and port. This allows this information to be used within the application protocol to assist in securing the connection. (This information is crucial to securing FTP sessions with GSSAPI Kerberos 5.) After 1995, the IETF began working on a successor to the SOCK 4 protocol. This work produced SOCKS Version 5 ([525]RFC 1928). SOCKS 5 is significantly more general than version 4. In addition to supporting client to server TCP/IP connections, it provides two crucial sets of functionality not found in previous protocols: * Authenticated firewall traversal of UDP/IP packets. * Authenticated binding of incoming public ports on the firewall. This allows a service on the private network to offer public services. It also allows client applications such as FTP to establish a temporary public presence that can be used by the FTP server to create a data channel. By allowing the client bind to a public port on the firewall and be aware of the public address, SOCKS 5 allows the application protocol to communicate that information to the server. C-Kermit can be built using either SOCKS 4 or SOCKS 5. Configuration of the SOCKS servers is determined by the requirements of the SOCKS library. Kermit 95 2.00 supports SOCKS 4.2. The SOCKS Server is specified with the command: SET TCP SOCKS-SERVER hostname/ip-address It should be noted that the best part about the SOCKS protocols is that each and every application does not need to implement them. Instead, SOCKS can be built into the IP stack on each host operating system and the protocols could work transparently without any change to the programs already shipped. II.2 Network Address Translation [ [526]Top ] [ [527]Contents ] [ [528]Appendix Contents ] [ [529]Glossary ] Network Address Translation (NAT) is a technique used to allow a single public IP address provided by an Internet Service Provider (ISP) to be shared among multiple computers on a private IP based network. NAT technology is often found in routers designed for the Home and Small Office market. This technique is wonderful as long as the application protocols being used do not require knowledge of the IP addresses being used. In fact, NATs when combined with SOCKS Version 5 would be a perfect solution except that we have never seen a product that combines these two technologies. (It is most likely a chicken-and-egg situation. No client applications support SOCKS 5, therefore no router manufacturers feel pressure to produce them. Since no routers support SOCKS 5, application vendors do not implement it.) NAT has particularly bad implications for Kerberos authentication that traditionally embeds into the ticket the IP addresses on which the ticket is valid. Another protocol that is adversely affected by NAT is FTP. However, FTP passive mode works around it. As luck would have it. Kerberos 4 has no problem with NAT because the Kerberos 4 ticket has room for only a single IP address and that IP address is assigned not by the client but by the KDC. The result is that when Kerberos 4 is used from behind a NAT the IP address that is placed into the ticket is the public IP address of the NAT, not the IP address of the client machine. This means the ticket is good only on the far side of the NAT and not on the near side. Kerberos 5 on the other hand is seriously affected by NAT. The addresses are stored in the ticket by the client. This allows the ticket to support the multiple addresses needed for multi-homed systems. However, when NAT is used, it is the private IP address that is stored into the ticket and not the public address seen by the KDC. If this ticket is now used to access a service on the public network, the service rejects the Kerberos 5 ticket since the IP address in the ticket does not match the source IP address used to establish the connection. This can be worked around if the client uses a kinit that allows a list of additional IP addresses to be specified for inclusion in the TGT. Kermit supports this capability with one of the following commands: AUTH K5 INIT /ADDRESSES:{list-of-addresses} SET AUTH K5 ADDRESSES {list-of-addresses} The problem with this solution is that, although it is secure, in most cases the end user does not know which IP address is assigned to the far side of the NAT. In this situation it is necessary to remove all IP addresses from the TGT. Kermit provides the AUTH K5 INIT /NO-ADDRESSES and SET AUTH K5 NO-ADDRESSES ON commands for this purpose. However, this solution is less secure since a TGT with no specified IP addresses can be used from any machine. Stolen TGTs are therefore extremely useful to a thief. We strongly advise that removing the IP address information from Kerberos 5 tickets not be performed on computers using file based caches as they are particularly vulnerable to theft. Sometimes it is possible to read the public address from the device providing NAT, as shown in the following Kermit script: [530]ftp://kermit.columbia.edu/kermit/scripts/ckermit/linksys For those interested in more technical information on the consequences of Network Address Translation, the IETF has several Informational RFCs on the subject: Architectural Implications of NAT [531]ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc2993.txt IP Network Address Translator (NAT) Terminology and Considerations [532]ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc2663.txt Traditional IP Network Address Translator (Traditional NAT) [533]ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc3002.txt NAT Friendly Application Design Guidelines [534]http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-ietf-nat-app-gui de-06.txt Keith Moore's "What NATs Break" [535]http://www.cs.utk.edu/~moore/what-nats-break.html II.3 Multi-Homed Hosts and Aliasing [ [536]Top ] [ [537]Contents ] [ [538]Appendix Contents ] [ [539]Glossary ] IP socket connections are established using IP addresses and port numbers. Human beings do not remember large groups of numbers well. Instead we remember do a better job remembering names. The Domain Name Service (DNS) is globally distributed database that converts between the names that humans recognize and the IP addresses that allow the desired service to be communicated with. There are two situations where multiple IP addresses can be associated with the same computer or service. The first is a computer that has multiple network interfaces. This is known as a multi-homed computer. Each interface is assigned its own IP address. The second situation is where a DNS name resolves to multiple computers. This is referred to as aliasing. Both can play havoc with authentication when using either Kerberos or X.509 certificates. Kermit is designed to support multi-homed computers and those with multiple names. Unfortunately, not everything else is. Kerberos 4 does not support multi-homed computers. Its ticket format only has space for a single IP address. If you are using Kermit as a client with Kerberos 4 authentication you must be sure to set the network interface you use for establishing your connections to match the one stored in the Kerberos 4 ticket. The ticket address can be viewed with the command: AUTH K4 LIST The interface to be used can be configured with: SET TCP ADDRESS There is no method for automating this process at the current time. Kerberos 5 has no problem with multihomed hosts because the ticket supports multiple IP addresses and those IP addresses are inserted into the ticket by the client, not by the KDC. There can also be problems when a host is being accessed through a DNS alias. The administrator for the host needs to install the service keys for both the unique hostname and the alias name in the Kerberos 4 service key file. When this is not done it can lead to problems because the service key retrieved by the client does not match the one used by the service. Kermit attempts to compensate for this by resolving the DNS alias the to real hostname. However, this does not always work on Windows 95 or Windows NT 3.5x due to their caching of DNS information. For instance, at Columbia University the CUNIX name resolves to one of six machines, each with a different name, such as HOSTA, HOSTB, etc. When telneting to CUNIX, you might be given IP address 128.59.35.136. But even though the DNS servers are properly configured to return the proper name (e.g. HOSTB) for that IP address, Windows 95 returns CUNIX because it retrieves the information from its internal cache instead of performing another network call. This means that instead of retrieving a Kerberos 4 ticket for the service: rcmd.hostb@CC.COLUMBIA.EDU we get a ticket for: rcmd.cunix@CC.COLUMBIA.EDU This use of the wrong ticket produces the following error: Can't decode authenticator (krb_rd_req) DNS aliases and multiple addresses can be a problem for connections protected with SSL/TLS. To maximize their revenue streams, most commercial certificate authorities do not issue certificates with multiple hostnames and/or IP addresses. Therefore the hostname used to access the service has to match the one that used in the certificate. Although Kermit can resolve aliases to unique hostnames for Kerberos, it cannot do so for X.509 certificates. When you are acting as your own Certificate Authority using the OpenSSL tools you can produce certificates containing multiple hostnames and IP addresses. Kermit authenticates connections correctly when presented with these certificates. [ [540]C-Kermit ] [ [541]C-Kermit 8.0 ] [ [542]Kermit 95 ] [ [543]Kermit Home ] ________________________________________________________________________ APPENDIX III: INTRODUCTION TO CERTIFICATES WITH OPENSSL [ [544]Top ] [ [545]Contents ] [ [546]Glossary ] CONTENTS III.1. [547]What Are Certificates (etc)...? III.2. [548]RSA vs DSA Certifications III.3. [549]Should You Be Your Own Certificate Authority? III.4. [550]Generating a DSA CA (self-signed) Certificate III.5. [551]Generating a DSA CSR III.6. [552]Generating an RSA CA (self-signed) certificate III.7. [553]Generating an RSA CSR III.8. [554]Signing a CSR with your CA certificate III.9. [555]Revoking a Certificate III.10. [556]Generating a CRL III.11. [557]Mapping a Client Certificate to a User ID LINKS * [558]IETF Public-Key Infrastructure (X.509) (pkix) Charter * [559]RFC 2459: Internet X.509 Public Key Infrastructure - Certificate and CRL Profile * [560]RFC 2527: Internet X.509 Public Key Infrastructure - Certificate Policy and Certification Practices Framework * [561]RFC 2528: Internet X.509 Public Key Infrastructure - Representation of Key Exchange Algorithm (KEA) Keys in Internet X.509 Public Key Infrastructure Certificates This is a brief introduction to certificates, certificate authorities, and how to use them. The information presented here is highly technical and can be skipped unless: * you are a system administrator and want to learn how to secure your host, or: * you want to know how to use client certificates to authenticate to a host. RSA Security, Inc., has a good Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ): [562]http://www.rsasecurity.com/rsalabs/faq/questions.html The FAQ covers many topics related to cryptography as well as how public key certificates work and how they are to be used. III.1. What Are Certificates, Private Keys, CSRs, CAs, and CRLs? [ [563]Top ] [ [564]Contents ] [ [565]Appendix Contents ] [ [566]Glossary ] Public key (asymmetric) cryptography defines a class of algorithms for key exchange that include RSA and Diffie-Hellman (DH). These algorithms provide a mechanism to create a shared secret that can be used for encrypting future communications. Anyone listening to the exchange would be no closer to figuring out the value of the shared secret than if they were to take a guess. There are two parts to the exchange. A private key that is never disclosed, and a public key that may be viewed by all. An X.509 certificate is a standard package for distributing a public key with identifying features such that the authenticity and validity of the public key may be verified by a recipient. The authenticity and validity of a certificate is provided by a combination of information provided within the certificates (the subject, the issuer, dates of validity, ...) as well as the trust that is placed in the certificate issuer (the Certificate Authority, or CA). The CA signs each of the certificates that it issues with its own certificate. With a copy of the CA's certificate it is possible to validate all of the certificates that were signed by the CA's private key. A user who wants to have a certificate signed by a CA creates a Certificate Signing Request (CSR). The CSR is an unsigned certificate presented to the CA along with information verifying the identity and desired use for the certificate. The CA signs the CSR producing a certificate that is valid for a specific time frame, which is then returned to the user. If the private key of the certificate were to be compromised the CA may revoke the certificate. The CA publishes a Certificate Revocation List (CRL) on a periodic basis containing a list of all certificates that would otherwise be valid if they were not revoked. It is the responsibility of the verifier to check not only the authenticity of the certificate but also whether or not it has been revoked by the issuer. III.2. RSA Certificates vs DSA Certificates [ [567]Top ] [ [568]Contents ] [ [569]Appendix Contents ] [ [570]Glossary ] The important differences between RSA and DSA certificates are: * The RSA algorithms are faster than DSA. * The RSA algorithms are supported by all the major browsers whereas DSA are not. * The RSA algorithms were patented in the United States (until Sept 29, 2000), requiring payments of licensing fees for producers of software utilizing them, whereas DSA is free. * The RSA private and public key pairs may be used for encrypting data as well as signing. DSA private and public key pairs may only be used for signing. Therefore, products incorporating DSA algorithms are easier to export from the United States. Due to the patent issues surrounding the RSA algorithms, the Kermit Project does not maintain a library or distribute any binaries that are built with the RSA algorithms. This policy can change when the RSA patent expires. III.3. Should You Be Your Own Certificate Authority? [ [571]Top ] [ [572]Contents ] [ [573]Appendix Contents ] [ [574]Glossary ] There are many companies that believe that providing CA services is big business. These include but are not limited to: * [575]Verisign * [576]Thawte Consulting * [577]CertiSign Cerificadora Digital Ltda. * [578]IKS GmbH * [579]Uptime Commerce Ltd. * [580]BelSign NV/SA The root CA certificates of these companies certificates are included most of the popular browsers. This provides an ease-of-use advantage to the recipients of certificates they sign since the root certificates do not need to be otherwise distributed to authenticate the signed certificates. On the other hand, as is pointed out by C. Ellison and B. Schneier in their paper, Ten Risks of PKI: What You're Not Being Told About Public Key Infrastructure: [581]http://www.counterpane.com/pki-risks.html using the commercial CA services it makes it difficult to decide whether or not a certificate should be trusted for a particular purpose, especially if you want to use certificates to authenticate an end user to a system for remote access. In this situation it is necessary to not only be able to authenticate a certificate but be able to know that the information within the certificate, such as the uniqueIdentifier used for the User ID, is tightly controlled and in fact unique in your environment. If you choose to be your own CA you will have to configure your environment. Create the following directory trees to store the DSA and RSA CAs. openssl/dsaCA/certs/ openssl/dsaCA/crl/ openssl/dsaCA/private/ openssl/dsaCA/newcerts/ openssl/dsaCA/requests/ openssl/rsaCA/certs/ openssl/rsaCA/crl/ openssl/rsaCA/private/ openssl/rsaCA/newcerts/ openssl/rsaCA/requests/ Place the openssl.cnf file into the openssl directory. Edit it to meet the requirements of your organization. Create two sections, [ CA_DSA ] and [ CA_RSA ]: [ CA_DSA ] dir = openssl_path/dsaCA/ # Where everything is kept certs = $dir/certs # Where the issued certs are kept crl_dir = $dir/crl # Where the issued crl are kept database = $dir/index.txt # database index file. new_certs_dir = $dir/newcerts # default place for new certs. certificate = $dir/certs/cacert.pem # The CA certificate serial = $dir/ca.srl # The current serial number crl = $dir/crl.pem # The current CRL private_key = $dir/private/cakey.pem # The private key RANDFILE = $dir/private/.rand # private random number file x509_extensions = x509v3_extensions # The extensions to add to the cert default_days = 365 # how long to certify for default_crl_days= 30 # how long before next CRL default_md = sha1 # which md to use. preserve = no # keep passed DN ordering policy = policy_match # which CA policy [ CA_RSA ] dir = openssl_path/rsaCA/ # Where everything is kept certs = $dir/certs # Where the issued certs are kept crl_dir = $dir/crl # Where the issued crl are kept database = $dir/index.txt # database index file. new_certs_dir = $dir/newcerts # default place for new certs. certificate = $dir/certs/cacert.pem # The CA certificate serial = $dir/ca.srl # The current serial number crl = $dir/crl.pem # The current CRL private_key = $dir/private/cakey.pem # The private key RANDFILE = $dir/private/.rand # private random number file x509_extensions = x509v3_extensions # The extensions to add to the cert default_days = 365 # how long to certify for default_crl_days= 30 # how long before next CRL default_md = sha1 # which md to use. preserve = no # keep passed DN ordering policy = policy_match # which CA policy If you wish to use the uniqueIdentifier field to perform certificate to user ID mapping, add it after the emailAddress field. If you wish to use the subjectAltName field to perform certificate to user ID mapping, you must to add a [ x509v3_extensions ] section: [ x509v3_extensions ] subjectAltName = email:copy Other formats of the subjectAltName field are: subjectAltName = email:copy subjectAltName = issuerl:copy subjectAltName = email:fred@company.com subjectAltName = DNS:www.company.com subjectAltName = IP:100.99.98.97 subjectAltName = RID:2.99999.1 Other x509v3 extensions include: nsCaRevocationUrl = http://www.domain.com/ca-crl.pem nsComment = "This is a comment" To avoid the need to specify the location of the openssl.cnf file, set the environment variable OPENSSL_CNF to be equal to the full path of the file. If you do not create this environment variable you must to include the option: -config path/openssl.cnf to each openssl command. Create the file that stores the next available serial number for each CA: openssl/dsaCA/ca.srl openssl/rsaCA/ca.srl The format of this file is a hex value followed by a LF (0x0A) character. The value "01" is an appropriate initial value. Create an empty file to store the index of signed certificates: openssl/dsaCA/index.txt openssl/rsaCA/index.txt Now you are ready to create the DSA and RSA CA certificates for your organization. III.4. Generating a DSA CA (self-signed) Certificate [ [582]Top ] [ [583]Contents ] [ [584]Appendix Contents ] [ [585]Glossary ] Change the current working directory to openssl/dsaCA/. Generate the DSA parameters to be used when generating the keys for use with your certificates: openssl dsaparam 1024 -out dsa1024.pem Generate the self-signed certificate to be used as the CA certificate for your organization: openssl req -x509 -newkey dsa:dsa1024.pem -days days \ -keyout private/cakey.pem -out certs/cacert.pem The days parameter should be replaced by the number of days you want this certificate to remain valid. All certificates signed by this certificate become invalid when this certificate expires. Be sure to not forget the pass-phrase you use to protect the private key of the CA certificate. If you do not wish to encrypt the CA's private key you may specify the -nodes option. But this is highly discouraged. You can check the contents of the CA certificate with the command: openssl x509 -text -in certs/cacert.pem III.5. Generating a DSA CSR [ [586]Top ] [ [587]Contents ] [ [588]Appendix Contents ] [ [589]Glossary ] Change the current working directory to openssl/dsaCA/. If you have not already created a set of DSA parameters, you must generate a set: openssl dsaparam 1024 -out dsa1024.pem It is safe to reuse the DSA parameters. Generate the DSA certificate request: openssl req -newkey dsa:dsa1024.pem -keyout private/name-key.pem \ -out requests/name-req.pem where name should be replaced by something that identifies the files. Perhaps the hostname or userid for which the certificate is being generated. If you are generating a CSR for use as a host certificate, be sure to specify the fully qualified domain name as reported by the DNS as the Common Name for the certificate. Otherwise, it won't be recognized as belonging to the host it is installed on by its clients. Be sure not to forget the pass-phrase you use to protect the private key of the CA certificate. The certificate (after signing) is unusable without it. Use the -nodes option if you wish to store the key unencrypted. You can check the contents of the CSR with the command: openssl req -text -in requests/name-req.pem The CSR now stored in requests/name-req.pem may be sent to one of the commercial CAs if you do not wish to be your own CA. III.6. Generating an RSA CA (self-signed) certificate [ [590]Top ] [ [591]Contents ] [ [592]Appendix Contents ] [ [593]Glossary ] Change the current working directory to openssl/rsaCA/. Generate the self-signed certificate to be used as the CA certificate for your organization: openssl req -x509 -newkey rsa:1024 -days days \ -keyout private/cakey.pem -out certs/cacert.pem The days parameter should be replaced by the number of days you want this certificate to remain valid. All certificates signed by this certificate become invalid when this certificate expires. Be sure not to forget the pass-phrase you use to protect the private key of the CA certificate. If you do not wish to encrypt the CA's private key you may specify the -nodes option. But this is highly discouraged. You can check the contents of the CA certificate with the command: openssl x509 -text -in certs/cacert.pem III.7. Generating an RSA CSR [ [594]Top ] [ [595]Contents ] [ [596]Appendix Contents ] [ [597]Glossary ] Change the current working directory to openssl/rsaCA/. openssl req -newkey rsa:1024 -keyout private/name-key.pem \ -out requests/name-req.pem name should be replaced by something that identifies the files, such as the hostname or userid for which the certificate is being generated. If you are generating a CSR for use as a host certificate be sure to specify the fully qualified domain name as reported by the DNS as the Common Name for the certificate. Otherwise, it is not recognized as belonging to the host it is installed on by its clients. Be sure not to forget the pass-phrase you use to protect the private key of the CA certificate. The certificate (after signing) is unusable without it. Use the -nodes option if you wish to store the key unencrypted. You can check the contents of the CSR with the command: openssl req -text -in requests/name-req.pem The CSR now stored in requests/name-req.pem may be sent to one of the commercial CAs if you do not wish to be your own CA. III.8. Signing a CSR with your CA certificate [ [598]Top ] [ [599]Contents ] [ [600]Appendix Contents ] [ [601]Glossary ] If you are signing a DSA certificate change directory to openssl/dsaCA/ and use a caname of "CA_DSA". If you are signing an RSA certificate change directory to openssl/rsaCA/ and use a caname of "CA_RSA": openssl ca -name caname -in requests/name-req.pem \ -out certs/name.pem -days days The days parameter should be replaced by the number of days you want the signed certificate to remain valid. If you want to specify a specific date range you can replace the -days parameters with: -startdate YYMMDDHHMMSSZ - certificate validity notBefore -enddate YYMMDDHHMMSSZ - certificate validity notAfter The file certs/name.pem now contains a signed certificate that may be used by a host or client for authentication with its matching private key (private/name-key.pem.) An alternative method of signing the CSR is to use the command: openssl x509 -req -in requests/name-req.pem -CA certs/cacert.pem \ -CAkey private/cakey.pem -out certs/name.pem -days days \ -CAserial ca.srl -CAcreateserial The "openssl x509" command provides greater functionality at the expense of ease of use. The X509 may be used to assign X.509v3 certificate extensions with the -extfile and -extensions switches. It may also be used to produce certificates that may only be used for specific purposes. You can check the contents of the CA certificate with the command: openssl x509 -text -in certs/name.pem III.9. Revoking a Certificate [ [602]Top ] [ [603]Contents ] [ [604]Appendix Contents ] [ [605]Glossary ] If you are revoking a DSA certificate change directory to openssl/dsaCA/ and use a caname of "CA_DSA". If you are revoking an RSA certificate change directory to openssl/rsaCA/ and use a caname of "CA_RSA". openssl ca -name caname -revoke certs/name.pem marks the certificate as being revoked in the index.txt file. It is necessary to revoke a certificate with a given subject name if you wish to generate a new certificate with an identical subject name. Once a certificate is revoked it is listed in the next generated CRL. III.10. Generating a CRL [ [606]Top ] [ [607]Contents ] [ [608]Appendix Contents ] [ [609]Glossary ] If you are generating a CRL for your DSA certificates change directory to openssl/dsaCA/ and use a caname of "CA_DSA". If you are generating a CRL for your RSA certificate change directory to openssl/rsaCA/ and use a caname of "CA_RSA": openssl ca -name caname -gencrl -out crl/date-crl.pem date should be replaced by the date the crl was generated. You can check the contents of the CRL with the command: openssl crl -in crl/date-crl.pem -text The current CRL should be placed somewhere it is publicly and easily accessible. For instance, by HTTP or FTP. The CRL is signed by the CA certificate III.11. Mapping a Client Certificate to a User ID [ [610]Top ] [ [611]Contents ] [ [612]Appendix Contents ] [ [613]Glossary ] Kermit can be configured to perform a mapping from an X.509 client certificate to a User ID. This is primarily of use when Kermit is installed as an Internet Kermit Service. When a mapping is enabled, the client certificate may be used to authenticate and automatically login a user to their account or resources. Unfortunately, it is not possible to build a function in to Kermit to provide the mapping from Certificate to User ID that would be secure and/or applicable to every installation. There are several commonly used approaches to map a certificate to a userid. Kermit can be customized to use whichever one you choose to use in your environment. Map the X.509 uniqueIdentifier field to the User ID The uniqueIdentifier field of the X.509 client certificate can include the userid of the end user. For instance, John Doe's uniqueIdentifier might be jdoe. A mapping function can extract the contents of this field and return it as the User ID. The problem with this approach is the uniqueIdentifier may not be very unique. Let us assume that you do not want to go through the trouble of managing your own Certificate Authority because it is too much work. So you refer all of your clients to request X.509 certificates from one of the commercial Certificate Authorities. It is possible that another site is doing exactly the same thing and that this other site has a user Jane Doe with User ID jdoe. In this circumstance, simply verifying the certificate against the CA certificate and extracting the uniqueIdentifier results in a security hole since Jane Doe would be able to gain access to John Doe's account. Map the X.509 subjectAltName to the User ID The subjectAltName field of the X.509 client certificate can include the e-mail address of the user instead of simply the userid of the user. In the case of John Doe, his subjectAltName would be jdoe@mydomain.com whereas Jane Doe's subjectAltName would be jdoe@someotherdomain.com. A mapping function using the subjectAltName can extract the contents of the subjectAltName, verify the domain is correct and then return the User ID. This method is safer than the uniqueIdentifier, but it is still placing a lot of trust in the Certificate Authority. If you are not issuing the certificates yourself you'll have to trust that the CA has a legitimate method for verifying that the e-mail address belongs to the user for whom the CA is signing a certificate. Map the Entire Certificate to the User ID Instead of trusting the contents of one of the fields within the certificate you can require that your user's submit their certificates for registration prior to use. The mapping function can then lookup the certificate in a local database or an LDAP server to retrieve the User ID. Of the methods described, this is the most secure. In addition to determining which userid is associated with a given client certificate, it is just as important to know whether or not the user is actually authorized to access the service when the certificate is provided. The X509_userok() function determines whether or not the combination of the provided X509 certificate and username is valid for automatic login. Whereas X509_to_user() is used to provide authentication of the user, the X509_userok() function is used to provide authorization. The certificate passed into X509_userok() does need to map to a userid; nor would the userid it would map to need to match the userid provided to the function. There are numerous circumstances in which it is beneficial to have the ability for multiple users to gain access to a common account such as 'root' on Unix; or a class account on a web server. In Unix this capability can be provided with a ~userid/.tlslogin file that contains a list of X509 certificates thatMay can be used to access the account userid. III.11.1. Mapping a Client Certificate to a User ID in Kermit 95 [ [614]Top ] [ [615]Contents ] [ [616]Appendix Contents ] [ [617]Glossary ] X.509 to User ID mapping functions are implemented in Kermit 95 via the use of a user compiled Dynamic Link Library (DLL), X5092UID.DLL. To build this DLL you need a C compiler such as Microsoft's Visual C++ and OpenSSL 0.9.4 (or higher) compiled and installed. OpenSSL sources may be retrieved from the web site: [618]http://www.openssl.org/ As of this writing the current release of OpenSSL is 0.9.6b and 0.9.7 is under development. Kermit 95 1.1.20 works OpenSSL binaries produced by compiling versions 0.9.4 or higher. Patches for OpenSSL 0.9.4 to allow compilation under OS/2 are located at: [619]http://www.geocities.com/SiliconValley/Hills/8057/files/openssl.html On Windows, OpenSSL must be compiled and linked to use the NT DLL option without Debug information. Compiling the DLLs with support for debugging links the DLLs to an incompatible C Run Time Library DLL. On OS/2, OpenSSL must be compiled to use the DLL version of the run time library. The DLL must contain two functions with the following prototypes: /* X509_to_user() returns 0 if valid userid in 'userid', else -1 */ int X509_to_user(X509 *peer_cert, char *userid, int len); /* X509_userok() returns 0 if access is denied; 1 is access is permitted */ int X509_userok(X509 * peer_cert, const char * userid); An example function that uses the /UID field of the Certificate Subject name follows: int X509_to_user(X509 *peer_cert, char *userid, int len) { int err; if (!(peer_cert && userid) || len <= 0) return -1; /* Userid is in cert subject /UID */ err = X509_NAME_get_text_by_NID(X509_get_subject_name(peer_cert), NID_uniqueIdentifier, userid, len); if (err > 0) return 0; return -1; } An example function provides userid authorization follows: int X509_userok(X509 * peer_cert, const char * userid) { /* check if clients cert is in "user"'s ~/.tlslogin file */ char buf[512]; int r = 0; FILE *fp; struct passwd *pwd; X509 *file_cert; if ( peer_cert == NULL ) return(0); if (!(pwd = getpwnam(userid))) return 0; if (strlen(pwd->pw_dir) > 500) return(0); sprintf(buf, "%s/.tlslogin", pwd->pw_dir); if (!(fp = fopen(buf, "r"))) return 0; while (!r && (file_cert = PEM_read_X509(fp, NULL, NULL, NULL))) { if (signature, file_cert->signature)) r = 1; X509_free(file_cert); } fclose(fp); return(r); } These functions must be compiled into a DLL called "X5092UID.DLL". It should be linked to the OpenSSL libraries and the DLL version of the run time library. Contact [620]Kermit Support for further information.. III.11.2 Mapping a Client Certificate to a User ID in C-Kermit [ [621]Top ] [ [622]Contents ] [ [623]Appendix Contents ] [ [624]Glossary ] X.509 to User ID mapping functions are implemented in C-Kermit in one of two ways. * If you want to use the uniqueIdentifier field you can specify KFLAGS=-DX509_UID_TO_USER at compile time. * If you want to use the subjectAltName field you can specify KFLAGS=-DX509_SUBJECT_ALT_NAME_TO_USER at compile time. * Otherwise, you need to customize the X509_to_user() function in the ck_ssl.c source file to implement your verification method. A X509_userok() that supports the use of the ~userid/.tlslogin file is provided. This function should be examined for compatibility with the institutional access policies. It should be replaced or modified as needed. Contact [625]Kermit Support for further information.. ________________________________________________________________________ GLOSSARY [ [626]Top ] [ [627]Contents ] ARPANET The US Department of Defense [628]Advanced Research Projects Agency Network, the precursor to the Internet. Authentication The process by which one entity proves its identity to another entity on the Internet. Authorization The process by which one gains access to a particular resource. CA SSL/TLS X.509 Certificate Authority. Certificate A public security key packaged in a way that allows its verification. Client (Kerberos) An entity that can obtain a ticket (see Ticket). Credentials Cache (Kerberos) The location where Kerberos stores tickets. The credentials cache can be a file or a buffer in memory. CAST An encryption algorithm similar to DES (q.v.). CRL SSL/TLS X.509 Certificate Revocation List. CSR SSL/TLS X.509 Certificate Signing Request. DES USA Federal Information Processing Standard (FIPS) [629]46-2 Data Encryption Standard (1988, 1993). DNS Domain Name System (which resolves IP hostnames into numeric IP addresses). DNSSEC [630]Domain Name System Security. Entity In this document, a user, host, or service. Expiration (Kerberos) Invalidation of a ticket after a certain period of time. A ticket's lifetime is chosen by the user when obtaining the ticket; the maximum allowable lifetime for different kinds of tickets is set by the site administrator. FTP File Transfer Protocol. On the Internet, this refers to a specific protocol defined in [631]RFC 959 and its followons. Forwardable Tickets (Kerberos) Tickets that can be forwarded (copied) to a remote machine, where they can be used, eliminating the need to obtain new Ticket Granting Tickets (q.v.) on that machine, e.g. for Telnetting from machine A to machine B and then from machine B to machine C. Host A computer that can be accessed over a network. HTTP Hyper Text Transfer Protocol, the protocol of the World Wide Web, [632]RFC 2616. IETF The [633]Internet Engineering Task Force, the body that sets standards for use on the Internet. IKSD [634]Internet Kermit Service Daemon. IPsec [635]IP Security Protocol. IPv6 [636]Internet Protocol Version 6, the "next generation" Internet protocol. ITU-T International Telecommunications Union, the body that sets international X-dot-series standards. Integrity The assurance that traffic on a network connection has not been altered in transit. KDC (Kerberos) Key Distribution Center, a machine that issues Kerberos tickets. PGP [637]Pretty Good Privacy, the original do-it-yourself public key security scheme, first developed in 1991 by Phil Zimmerman. Preauthenticated Ticket Granting Ticket Request (Kerberos) The client must include a time stamp encrypted with the user's password when requesting the TGT from the KDC. This allows the KDC to only deliver a TGT to a valid user. When preauthentication is not used the TGT may be attacked offline to determine the user's password. NAT Network Address Translator. NTLM Microsoft (Windows) NT LAN Manager authentication protocol. PKI Public Key Infrastructure. Postdated Ticket (Kerberos) A ticket that does not become valid until after a specified time. This allows for secure unattended operations. Principal (Kerberos) A string that names a specific entity to which a set of credentials may be assigned. It generally has three parts, primary/instance@REALM: 1. Primary: Identifies the user or service. 2. Instance: Usually a hostname or REALM. 3. REALM: Logical network served by a single Kerberos database and KDC. Privacy The assurance that traffic on a network connection is intelligible only to the two communicating parties. Proxiable Ticket (Kerberos) A ticket that may be given to a service to allow the service to impersonate the user for whom the ticket has been issued. SSL Secure Sockets Layer, developed by/for Netscape for secure Web connections. SOCKS Protocol for firewall traversal. SOCKS5 is an Internet standard ([638]RFC 1928). SSL/TLS SSL (q.v.) and/or TLS (q.v.). SRP Stanford University's Secure Remote Password protocol, a zero-knowledge based authentication method. TELNET ARPANET/Internet Network Virtual Terminal Protocol ("Teletype Network"), described in [639]RFC 854 plus many followons. Ticket (Kerberos) A temporary set of electronic credentials that verifies the identity of its owner to a particular service. TGT (Kerberos) Ticket Granting Ticket. A special ticket that lets its owner obtain additional tickets within the same realm. A TGT is obtained during the initial authentication process. TLS Transport Layer Security, the Internet standard form of SSL (q.v.), [640]RFC 2246. X.509 ITU-T standard for exchanging public keys. ________________________________________________________________________ REFERENCES [ [641]Top ] [ [642]Contents ] 1. Schneier, Bruce, Applied Cryptography: Protocols, Algorithms, and Source Code in C, 2nd Edition, 784 pages, John Wiley & Sons; ISBN: 0471117099 (1995). 2. da Cruz, Frank, and Christine M. Gianone, Using C-Kermit, 2nd Edition, 622 pages, Digital Press / Butterworth Heinemann; ISBN: 1-55558-164-1 (1997) 3. [643]The Kermit Project Website 4. [644]RFC 854: Telnet Protocol Specification 5. [645]RFC 959: File Transfer Protocol (FTP) 6. [646]RFC 1282: BSD Rlogin 7. [647]RFC 1510: The Kerberos Network Authentication Service (V5) 8. [648]RFC 1928: SOCKS Protocol Version 5 9. [649]RFC 1964: The Kerberos Version 5 GSS-API Mechanism 10. [650]RFC 2217 Telnet Com Port Control Option 11. [651]RFC 2228: FTP Security Extensions 12. [652]RFC 2246: The TLS Protocol Version 1.0 13. [653]RFC 2663: IP Network Address Translator (NAT) Terminology and Considerations 14. [654]RFC 2459: Internet X.509 Public Key Infrastructure - Certificate and CRL Profile 15. [655]RFC 2527: Internet X.509 Public Key Infrastructure - Certificate Policy and Certification Practices Framework 16. [656]RFC 2528: Internet X.509 Public Key Infrastructure - Representation of Key Exchange Algorithm (KEA) Keys... 17. [657]RFC 2616: Hypertext Transfer Protocol -- HTTP/1.1 18. [658]RFC 2712: Addition of Kerberos Cipher Suites to Transport Layer Security (TLS) 19. [659]RFC 2818: HTTP over TLS 20. [660]RFC 2839: Internet Kermit Service 21. [661]RFC 2840: Telnet KERMIT Option 22. [662]RFC 2941: Telnet Authentication Option 23. [663]RFC 2942: Telnet Authentication: Kerberos Version 5 24. [664]RFC 2943: TELNET Authentication Using DSA 25. [665]RFC 2944: Telnet Authentication: SRP 26. [666]RFC 2945: The SRP Authentication and Key Exchange System 27. [667]RFC 2946: Telnet Data Encryption Option 28. [668]RFC 2947: Telnet Encryption: DES3 64 bit Cipher Feedback 29. [669]RFC 2948: DES3 64-bit Output Feedback Mode 30. [670]RFC 2949: CAST-128 64-bit Output Feedback Mode 31. [671]RFC 2950: CAST-128 64-bit Cipher Feedback Mode 32. [672]RFC 2951: DES 64-bit Output Feedback Mode 33. [673]RFC 2952: DES 64-bit Cipher Feedback Mode 34. [674]RFC 2953: Telnet Encryption: DES 64 bit Output Feedback 35. [675]RFC 2993: Architectural Implications of NAT 36. [676]RFC 3002: Traditional IP Network Address Translator (Traditional NAT) Also see: [677]http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/standards.html ________________________________________________________________________ TRADEMARKS [ [678]Top ] [ [679]Contents ] Kerberos Is a trademark of Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Secure Remote Password Is a trademark of Stanford University. Secure Shell Is a trademark of SSH Communications Security Corporation. SSH Is a registered trademark of SSH Communications Security Corporation. [ [680]Top ] [ [681]Contents ] [ [682]Glossary ] [ [683]C-Kermit Home ] [ [684]Kermit Home ] ______________________________________________________________ [685]Kermit Security Reference / [686]The Kermit Project / [687]Columbia University / [688]kermit-support@columbia.edu / 12 Dec 2001 References 1. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ 2. http://www.columbia.edu/ 3. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ck80.html 4. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/k95next.html 5. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security70.html 6. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ck70.html 7. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/k95.html 8. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/index.html 9. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ckermit.html 10. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/k95.html 11. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1 12. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x2 13. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 14. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4 15. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa1 16. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa2 17. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa3 18. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 19. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#references 20. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#trademarks 21. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 22. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 23. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 24. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x2 25. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.1 26. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.2 27. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.3 28. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.4 29. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.5 30. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 31. http://www.columbia.edu/acis/security/safecomputing.html 32. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#n01 33. http://www.ietf.org/html.charters/ipsec-charter.html 34. http://www.ipv6.org/ 35. http://www.ietf.org/ids.by.wg/dnssec.html 36. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ckermit.html 37. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/k95.html 38. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#trademarks 39. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#trademarks 40. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#trademarks 41. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#trademarks 42. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 43. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 44. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1 45. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 46. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 47. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 48. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1 49. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 50. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa3 51. ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc2228.txt 52. ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc2818.txt 53. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa3 54. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 55. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 56. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1 57. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 58. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.3.1 59. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.3.2 60. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.3.3 61. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.3.4 62. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.3.1 63. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa3 64. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.3.2 65. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 66. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 67. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1 68. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.3 69. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 70. ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc1510.txt 71. ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc1964.txt 72. http://web.mit.edu/kerberos/www/ 73. http://nii.isi.edu/info/kerberos/ 74. http://nii.isi.edu/publications/kerberos-neuman-tso.html 75. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 76. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 77. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1 78. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.3 79. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 80. ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc2945.txt 81. http://www-cs-students.stanford.edu/~tjw/srp/ 82. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 83. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 84. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1 85. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.3 86. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 87. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 88. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 89. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1 90. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.3 91. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 92. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa3 93. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 94. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 95. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1 96. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 97. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x2 98. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.4.1 99. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.4.2 100. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.4.3 101. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.4.4 102. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.4.5 103. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.4.6 104. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 105. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 106. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1 107. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.4 108. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 109. ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc2946.txt 110. ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc2950.txt 111. ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc2949.txt 112. ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc2947.txt 113. ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc2948.txt 114. ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc2952.txt 115. ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc2951.txt 116. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.4.3 117. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 118. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 119. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1 120. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.4 121. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 122. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 123. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 124. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1 125. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.4 126. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 127. ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc2246.txt 128. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa3 129. ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc2712.txt 130. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 131. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 132. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1 133. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.4 134. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 135. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 136. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 137. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1 138. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.4 139. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 140. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.4.3 141. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 142. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 143. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1 144. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1.4 145. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 146. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 147. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 148. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 149. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x1 150. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 151. http://www.mozilla.org/crypto-faq.html 152. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ckermit.html 153. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ck80.html 154. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/k95.html 155. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/index.html 156. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 157. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 158. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 159. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4 160. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x2 161. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.1 162. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2 163. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.3 164. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.4 165. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/k95bulk.html 166. mailto:kermit-support@columbia.edu 167. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.1.1 168. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.1.2 169. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.1.3 170. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.1.4 171. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.1.5 172. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 173. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 174. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 175. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.1 176. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 177. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 178. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 179. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 180. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.1 181. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 182. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 183. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 184. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 185. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.1 186. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 187. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 188. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 189. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 190. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.1 191. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 192. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa3 193. ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc2246.txt 194. ftp://kermit.columbia.edu/kermit/c-kermit/ca_certs.pem 195. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2.2.3 196. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/iksd.html 197. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa3.11 198. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa1.1 199. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa1 200. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa1.2 201. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 202. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 203. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 204. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.1 205. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 206. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 207. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 208. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 209. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 210. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2.1 211. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2.2 212. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2.3 213. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2.4 214. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ckututor.html 215. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/k95tutor.html 216. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ckscripts.html 217. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 218. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 219. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 220. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2 221. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 222. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2.1.1 223. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2.1.2 224. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2.1.3 225. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 226. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 227. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 228. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2 229. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2.1 230. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 231. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/telnet.html 232. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa1 233. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 234. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 235. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 236. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2 237. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2.1 238. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 239. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ftpclient.html 240. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 241. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 242. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 243. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2 244. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2.1 245. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 246. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 247. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 248. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 249. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2 250. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 251. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2.3 252. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa2 253. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 254. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 255. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 256. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2 257. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 258. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ckermit2.htm#x1.5 259. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ckermit2.htm 260. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 261. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ckb2.html 262. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ckermit2.htm#x1.6 263. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ckermit2.htm 264. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 265. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 266. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 267. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2 268. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 269. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa2 270. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ckermit.html 271. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ck80.html 272. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/k95.html 273. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/index.html 274. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 275. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 276. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 277. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 278. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.3.1 279. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.3.2 280. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.3.3 281. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.3.4 282. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.3.5 283. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.3.6 284. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.3.7 285. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 286. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 287. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 288. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.3 289. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 290. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 291. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 292. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 293. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.3 294. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 295. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 296. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 297. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 298. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.3 299. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 300. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 301. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 302. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 303. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.3 304. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 305. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 306. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 307. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 308. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.3 309. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 310. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 311. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 312. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 313. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.3 314. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 315. http://www.stunnel.org/ 316. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.2.2.3 317. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa3 318. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/case21.html 319. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 320. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 321. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 322. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3.3 323. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 324. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ckermit.html 325. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ck80.html 326. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/k95.html 327. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/index.html 328. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 329. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 330. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 331. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 332. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ckermit.html 333. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ck80.html 334. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/k95.html 335. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/index.html 336. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 337. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 338. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 339. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa1 340. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x3 341. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.1 342. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.2 343. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.1.1 344. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.1.2 345. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.1.3 346. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.1.4 347. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.1.5 348. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.1.6 349. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.1.7 350. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 351. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 352. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4 353. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.1 354. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 355. http://web.mit.edu/kerberos/www/ 356. ftp://ftp.cmf.nrl.navy.mil/pub/kerberos5/README 357. http://www.kermit-project.org/noexport.html 358. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.1.2 359. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 360. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 361. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4 362. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.1 363. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 364. http://www.kermit-project.org/noexport.html 365. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 366. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 367. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4 368. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.1 369. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 370. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 371. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 372. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4 373. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.1 374. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 375. http://www.kermit-project.org/noexport.html 376. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa3.11.1 377. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 378. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 379. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4 380. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.1 381. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 382. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 383. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 384. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4 385. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.1 386. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 387. ftp://ftp.nec.co.jp/pub/packages/sotools/ 388. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 389. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 390. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4 391. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.1 392. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 393. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/k95dll_c.txt 394. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 395. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 396. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4 397. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 398. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.2.1 399. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.2.2 400. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.2.3 401. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.2.4 402. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.2.5 403. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.2.6 404. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 405. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 406. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4 407. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.2 408. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 409. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/iksd.html 410. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x2 411. http://web.mit.edu/kerberos/www/ 412. http://web.mit.edu/network/kerberos-form.html 413. http://web.mit.edu/kerberos/www/ 414. http://web.mit.edu/network/kerberos-form.html 415. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/iksd.html 416. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 417. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 418. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4 419. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.2 420. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 421. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x2 422. http://srp.stanford.edu/srp/ 423. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/iksd.html 424. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 425. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 426. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4 427. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.2 428. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 429. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/iksd.html 430. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x2 431. http://www.openssl.org/ 432. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#xa3.11.2 433. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 434. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 435. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4 436. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.2 437. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 438. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 439. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 440. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4 441. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.2 442. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 443. http://www.kernel.org/pub/linux/libs/pam/Linux-PAM-html/ 444. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#top 445. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#contents 446. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4 447. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#x4.2 448. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/security80.html#glossary 449. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ckermit2.htm#x2.7 450. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ckermit2.htm 451. http://www.columbia.edu/kermit/ckccfg.html#x8.1.1>Section8.1.1ofthe