Distrust: Skin Shade, Expectations and Trust in Laboratory Experiments
Catherine C. Eckel
School of Social Sciences
University of Texas at Dallas, GR31
Richardson, Texas 75080
Phone: 972-883-4949
eckelc@utdallas.edu
Rick K. Wilson
Department of Political Science
Rice University
Houston, TX
rkw@rice.edu
Abstract:
We report the results of laboratory experiments designed to measure
racial/ethnic discrimination in trust behavior. Experiments are conducted
across two sites: a subject at one site observes the photograph of her
counterpart at the other site. Subjects play a discrete trust game: the
first mover decides whether to make a $10 loan to a counterpart. If made,
the $10 doubles, then the second mover decides how much to return. The
photographs taken during the experiment are then rated by a separate set of
raters for skin tone. We find that the probability the loan is made
varies by the skin tone of the counterpart: darker skin tones are associated
with lower levels of trust. We have no evidence of an in-group effect: all
groups appear to trust less a counterpart with a darker skin shade. This
effect holds even when adjusting for lower expectations of reciprocity
from darker-skinned counterparts. We find no evidence that reciprocity
differs by skin tone. |