CMSC     2004 Conference     Program      Abstracts     Concert     Columbia Music Department

Abstracts

9:30-11:00, Panel I: Music and Reception
Session Chair: Joshua Walden
 
  "The Orchestra Machine, Timbre, and the New Listener in the 18th Century"
    Emily Dolan, Cornell University
       The late 18th and early 19th centuries saw the creation of numerous bizarre musical instruments: the Orchestrion, Apollonion, Clavicyclinder, Panharmonican, etc.. Many of these were precursors to the large Orchestrions of the late 19th century popular in cafes throughout Europe and functioned as mechanical substitutes for the orchestra. While it is easy to view these instruments as mere curiosities, let us ask what motivated inventors of the late 18th century to create instruments that captured the sounds of the orchestra, and what these creations imply about the listening aesthetic of contemporary audiences. In this paper I will argue that during the late 18th century, timbre played an increasingly important role in music, affecting a major change in musical aesthetics. For much of the 18th century, music was conceptualized as a medium whose "meaning" depended on an association with the external world of nature, while the actual sounds of music had little aesthetic value. Yet, by the end of the eighteenth century, the unarticulated critical consensus about musical mimesis was increasingly called into question by a widespread interest in the immediate power of the orchestra - a power that did not originate in imitation, but rather in the myriad expressive timbres of instruments. Rather than seeking out music's connection to the outside world, the late 18th century listener could become enraptured by the immediacy of the orchestra. Mechanical reproductions of the orchestra were playful attempts at capturing this power of symphonic timbre. Rather than dismissing these inventions as novelty items, I believe we can see these as repositories of the essential elements of musical composition that captured the public imagination.
 
  "'Baroque Music in Israel': First Adaptations and transformations in the New Land"
    Maya Liberman-Weil, University of Tel Aviv
       This paper will present the special transformation that Baroque music underwent in the land of Israel (Palestine) during the first decades of the 20th century. The new immigrants from Europe brought with them a world of musical traditions and cultural codes, which they had to adapt to the local environment. Thus, for instance, German, mainly Christian texts were freely translated into Hebrew and infused with new messages and ideologies. This double entendre facilitated to a large extent the propagation of Baroque music throughout the country, and its integration into the musical repertory not only of concert programs but also of public festivities and pageants of national and agricultural character. In its new disguise, it was frequently performed in villages, cities and Kibbutzim (community settlements founded by the members of Zionist-socialist movements). The paper will discuss the historical, social and psychological meanings of this phenomenon and its contribution to the construction of a new culture in the new land.
 
  "Caruso and His Cousins: Portraits of Italian Americans in the Operatic Novelty Songs of Edwards and Madden"
    Larry Hamberlin, Brandeis University
 

     Between 1900 and 1920 more than three million Italians immigrated to the United States Most of those immigrants had little education and less money, and most of them settled in or near New York City. One result of this wave of immigration was a change in New York's audience for opera: at the very moment that cultural arbiters were repositioning opera as a high art demanding a cultivated audience, unrefined but enthusiastic Italian immigrants were filling the galleries at the Metropolitan Opera House, especially after the arrival in 1903 of Enrico Caruso.
      Documenting this demographic shift were operatic novelty songs-comic popular songs that allude to opera and were sung in vaudeville, musical comedies, and topical revues. Some of the best operatic novelties are the work of two Tin Pan Alley tunesmiths, Gus Edwards and Edward Madden, who between 1908 and 1912 wrote songs that comment satirically on the star status of Enrico Caruso and Luisa Tetrazzini and on the aspirations of would-be opera singers from the Italian American working class. Beyond their entertainment value, which is still considerable for listeners who can recognize the allusions, these songs shed light on opera reception in the United States during opera's transition from an art of the people to the reserve of a cultivated elite.
 

11:30-1:00 pm, Panel II: Musical Performance and Practice
Session Chair: Karen Hiles
 
  "Authority, Literary Agency, and Musical Authorship in the Works of Adam dela Halle"
    Jesus Ramos Kittrell, University of Texas at Austin
 

   Despite a lack of information on the lives of the trouvères archival research enables us to get a glimpse of their social activities and literary efforts. Close study of medieval vernacular poetry shows a linguistic affinity between the written practices of the poet and the clerk. Medieval musical structures further reflect a special treatment of poetic and musical forms, depicting a proficient authorship in both Latin and vernacular grounds.
    Medievalists have established Latin as the language of the "literate" people. This elite of individuals was familiar with concepts of reading and scripture that made written record a prime characteristic of Latin literacy. Vernacular practices, on the other hand, were customary to the larger part of an uneducated laity. These relied heavily on oral tradition, since the historicity of its testimony had more social significance. In this light, it is not possible to regard the development of vernacular literacy as a phenomenon suddenly derived from standardized Latin practices. It is rather the result of a change in thinking, a process of evolution that de-emphasized oral tradition to rely on concrete written practices.
     This paper shows that the musical practices of the trouvères provided an arena for linguistic negotiation, a space where literary modes mutually participated in shaping the emergence of a vernacular literacy. I therefore would like to explore the role of the trouvère as agent to this process and the impact that his poetry, delivered through music, had on the proliferation of a vernacular written practice in the middle ages.
 

  "Performing Instrumental Transgression: Camille Saint-Saëns's Carnival of the Animals in the fin-de-siècle salon"
    Erica Scheinberg, University of California at Los Angeles
       Although Camille Saint-Saëns's Carnival of the Animals has rarely been subjected to musicological criticism, this idiosyncratic work for chamber orchestra vividly inspires consideration of such under-discussed topics as the place of the "inside joke" in French fin-de siècle salon culture and the status of the site-specific musical performance in the musicological canon.
      This paper situates The Carnival of the Animals alongside Schumann's Carnaval, examining the ways that Saint-Saëns outdoes Schumann's model of an eccentric compositional framework in this work composed for the carnival season. In fact Saint-Saëns's "zoological fantasy" epitomizes carnivalesque transgression, in that it distorts conventional notions of temporality, depicts grotesque bodily gestures, and invents various kinds of musical masquerade and cross dressing. Furthermore, many aspects of the work suggest that it is a musical farce to be put on by the very people who are supposed to get it, evoking the spirit of carnival as described by Bakhtin.
      Saint-Saëns's musical depictions demand that the instrumentalists performing the piece impersonate themselves as "characters" in the salon, just as the instruments they play represent particular animals. Essential to the work is this kind of performing "about" performance, a notion that in effect literally materializes immaterial aspects of music such as melody and timbre and allows Saint-Saëns to invert the Romantic surface-depth paradigm by taking up instrumental materiality as one possible "substance" to be revealed within the context of late nineteenth century chamber music.
 
  "Powerful Voices: Performing and Interaction in Collegiate A Cappella"
    Joshua Duchan, University of Michigan at Ann Arbor
 

     On college and university campuses across the United States, small a cappella ensembles, largely student-run and without faculty involvement, have been growing in numbers and prominence over the past two decades. A distinguishing feature of these groups is their highly social nature. Within them, interaction is constant and a group's ultimate goal-the performance of its music-can be best understood as a result of this intense, musically shaped social interaction.
      By drawing on performance theory and Bourdieu's concepts of habitus and field, this paper proposes an understanding of collegiate a cappella groups as ensembles in which performance-formal and quotidian-is multi-contextual and dependent upon a multi-layered complex of musical and social interaction. Theoretical findings are supported with ethnographic data to illustrate multiple levels of interaction ranging from the personal to the group to the regional and the national. Performances of power shape the way individuals and groups interact, explaining both the consistency within and between groups as well as trends across larger scenes. Understanding this interaction in the collegiate a cappella context can be fruitful for understanding more general intersections between the musical and the personal, music and power, and musical and social performance.
 

3:30-5:30, Panel III: Musical Modernism and the Avant-Garde
Session Chair: Christopher Doll
 
  "Analyzing Poème Électronique as a Piece of Musical Multimedia"
    Hubert Ho, University of California at Berkeley
       In May 1958 the Philips Corporation unveiled its contribution to the 1958 World Exposition in Brussels: a multimedia spectacle designed to showcase how the corporation's technological products could be used in the making art. Le Corbusier, the selected architect, invited Edgar Varèse to write an accompanying musical score, dubbed Poème Électronique. While scholars have considered the Pavilion in terms of its place in architectural history, and while music scholars have considered ways of analyzing Poème as a piece of electroacoustic music, little attention has been devoted to the work as a piece of multimedia encompassing the varied genres of art displayed within the Pavilion. This paper attempts to rectify the situation by incorporating the views of film theories of Hans Eisler, Sergei Eisenstein, and Theodor Adorno, thus essentially reading the music of Poème Électronique as a film score, as it was presented in the Pavilion. It also attempts to challenge the Eisensteinian notion of juxtaposition and proposes Umberto Eco's notion of the "open work" as a driving force in the reception of the piece as an idiosyncratic yet compelling conglomeration of light and sound.
 
  "'A New Kind of Insanity': John Cage's Atlas Eclipticalis and the Challenges of Indeterminacy"
    Edgardo Salinas, Columbia University
 

     "You can come out from under you seat now, Aunt Martha, it's all over." With these comforting words to an imaginary subscriber, Alan Rich opened his review of a New York Phiharmonic concert held on 6 February 1964 caricaturing the reaction of performers, audience, and critics. The orchestra, under the glamorous baton of Leonard Bernstein, had played Atlas Eclipticalis by John Cage.
      Commissioned by Montreal Semaine Internationale de Musique Actuelle of 1961, Atlas Eclipticalis was Cage's first large orchestral project and a fruit of his radical phase in the realm of indeterminacy. The sketches of Atlas, which have not been he subject of previous scholarly study, reveal Cage's herculean effort to abandon all intention by opening through chance the creative process itself to an unpredictable intervention of performers.
      Confronted with a music that by no means fit into the work-concept framework, the critics deplored Atlas, calling it among other things "a new kind of insanity." Creating totally indeterminate music Cage subverted the notion of artwork by transfiguring it into an "open process." Cage's musical processes are ontological mutants whose inner nature resists the very idea of reification.

  "Modern Attention and Modernist Aurality in Helmholtz and Varèse"
    Benjamin Steege, Harvard University
 

     Helmholtz's psychophysiological harmonic theory appears broadly as a modernist program for reconfiguring the constitution of aurality for modern contexts. This occurred partly through shifting the notion of attention away from the Enlightenment assumption of a rapt, unified listening subject in order to account for an industrial-age, empiricist, specialist listener prone to distraction. This listener emerges at particular spots and moments in modernity, including the workshops of mid-nineteenth-century scientific- and musical-instrument builders and in the laboratories of post-Helmholtz experimental psychologists.
      A few decades later, Edgard Varèse would open a field for the play of exploratory attention in Octandre, which recapitulates some of the anxieties associated with Helmholtzian aurality. It comes as no surprise that his downtown-New-York apartment housed a laboratory space marked by the conditions similar to those in which this aurality had first emerged.
      In any of these contexts, distraction need not be assessed as pathological but frequently appears as co-present with and as flowing in and out of extreme attention, which is as fickle and fluttering as its subject is fallible. In spite of this paradox of the modern psychological listening subject, Helmholtz's and Varèse's shared enthusiasm for technological modernization cannot be separated from their shared interest in harnessing and honing attention as a means toward increasing the production of potential musical meaning.

  "Listening in on the première of Pierre Boulez's Structures 1a"
    Ben Parsons, St. Catherine's College, Oxford University
 

     To musicologists brought up since the heyday of post-War modernist analysis, Pierre Boulez's arrest in November 2001 on a charge of international terrorism was coloured by a somewhat uncomfortable irony. In the context of a historical process in which Boulez has been iconicised as a defender and legitimator of abstract organisational principles, we are not used to having to make the connection between him and the problems and politics of a real world that lies outside the narrowly defined serial aesthetic.
     This paper considers Boulez's Structures 1a (1952) in response to a challenge issued by Susan McClary in 1989 for new methodologies that would hope to reach a more critical understanding of serial music by thinking beyond the terms of formalist analysis. It takes the work's remarkable première - at an anti-Communist music festival backed by the CIA - as a starting point to argue that Boulez's musical thinking was shaped by tensions in the cultural politics of early Cold-War Paris. Drawing on contemporary aural responses to this first performance, it will re-examine our problematic placing of Structures 1a as an archetype of serial autonomy and counter the modernist defence that, for the young Boulez at least, music composed with the intention of being autonomous should also have been meaningless in any context outside itself.