Mediums and the New Media:
The Impact of Electronic Publishing on Temple and Moral Economies in Taiwanese Popular Religion

Philip Clart, University of Leipzig

Presented as part of a panel on "New Perspectives on Religion in China: Publishing Religion, Negotiating the Party-State"
American Academy of Religion Annual Meeting, San Francisco
Monday, November 21, 4:00 - 6:30pm

Screenshot of Temple Website

Figure 1: Screenshot of website for 武廟明正堂.


Screenshot of Temple Website

Figure 2: Screenshot of website for 全真堂.


Picture of Computers and Shrine

Figure 3: Picture of facilities in 武廟明正堂, 臺中市.

From the Introduction:

Religion’s role and fate on the Internet emerged in the 1990s as a hot new topic in religious studies and has stayed with us since then, spawning for example a panel at this AAR meeting on "Surveying Our Understanding of Digital Religion" (organized by the "Religion, Media, and Culture" group). Drawing on Walter Ong's theories of the impact of communication technologies on human consciousness and cultural innovation, in the early years expectations were high that online religion would create radically novel (and perhaps even better) ways of being religious and doing religion. This optimism has of late been dampened. Stephen D. O'Leary, one of the field’s early "prophets," is now taking a more guarded view, pointing out that by the mid- 2000's few religious websites had utilized the full communicative potential of the Web. While religious groups have rushed to embrace the Web as a largely one-way platform to get their message across, they have been more reluctant to come up with new interactive modes of religious communication and action. In the same conference volume as O'Leary's piece, Lorne L. Dawson considers the limitations of online religiosity in terms of the inbuilt reflexivity of computer-mediated communication. This may work well for fringe religious forms such as techno-paganism, but seems hard to reconcile with more traditional notions of authentic religious experience.

The present paper seeks to examine the forays into the Internet of one type of religious organization in Taiwan: spirit-writing cults, a.k.a. "phoenix halls" (luantang 鸞堂). The key activity of any phoenix hall is spirit-writing (fuji 扶乩, fuluan 扶鸞), i.e., the recording of texts authored by the cult group's gods through the services of a human medium wielding either a pen on paper, or a wooden, Y-shaped "planchette" (mubi 木筆, taobi 桃筆) on the sand-covered surface of a tray. Most of the texts thus produced are classified as "morality books" (shanshu 善書), texts admonishing people to moral reform and spiritual cultivation. Spirit-writing is not the only activity of a luantang, but is supplemented with numerous ritual and spiritual services, many of which are also performed by other groups. These include, for example, divinatory counselling (jishi 濟世), spiritual healing (lingliao 靈療), salvation of ancestors (chaoba 超拔), release of captive animals (fangsheng 放生), scripture recitation (songjing 誦經) etc. However, spirit-writing is the key (or perhaps, trademark) activity in that it defines the identity of a luantang vis-à-vis other religious groups that do not practise this form of mediumistic communication.


Download Full Paper (PDF, 149 KB)

Download Appendix (PDF, 102 KB)

Return to main panel page

Made with jEdit - Works best on all browsers