Credits

 
 
 
 
 
 


Ming, Qing, and Chosŏn Anthologies that Include Hŏ Nansŏrhŏn's Poems

After Hŏ Nansŏrhŏn's untimely death at the age of twenty-seven, her younger brother Hŏ Kyun collected all of her extant poems from her natal home, transcribed those he had memorized, and, in 1590, showed it to his Chinese teacher, Liu Chenglong 柳成龍, with the request that he compose a postscript. Although Liu's postscript was misplaced during the Hideyoshi invasions (1592-1598) and never published with the collection, the record of this episode provides strong evidence that manuscript copies of Hŏ Nansŏrhŏn's poems were being circulated in both the Chosŏn and the Ming dynasties well before the first publication of the Nansŏrhŏn Jip 雪蘭軒集 in 1608 in Chosŏn.

The following table provides an important tool for tracing the circulation of Hŏ Nansŏrhŏn's poetry in these dynasties, but especially in the Ming and Qing. While the same collection (Nansŏrhŏn Jip 雪蘭軒集) was published in three separate editions in seventeenth-century Chosŏn (1608, 1632, 1692), in China her poems were included to different extants in a wide variety of anthologies. The basic information about these anthologies is included below.

The paratexts, including prefaces, postscripts, brief biographies, and commentaries, are particularly useful for the part of our project that is exploring the creation and transmission of a place- and gender-specific cultural icon. Many of these texts are included in translation in "Biographical Accounts."

A number of recent careful studies of Nansŏrhŏn's legacy have been invaluable in the compilation of this material. These include "The actual situation of late Ming/early Qing documents that record the works of Hŏ Nansŏrhŏn of Chosŏn 明末清初文獻所錄朝鮮許蘭雪軒作品之實況" by Pak Hyŏnkyu 朴現圭 in Zhang Hongsheng 張宏生 ed., Literature and Gender in Ming-Qing China《 明清文學與性別研究》; Hŏ Mija's Study of Hŏ Nansŏrhŏn, or Hŏ Nansŏrhŏn Yŏn’gu, and Kang-i Sun Chang's chapter, "Ming and Qing Anthologies of Women's Poetry and Their Selection Strategies," in Ellen Widmer and Kang-i Sun Chang, ed. Writing Women in Late Imperial China. Please refer to the bibliography for complete references.

(
Date Title Region

Editor

Authors of Paratexts Description of Content Number of Nansŏrhŏn's Poems
1598 Chaoxian gushi
朝鮮古詩
(Old Poems of Chosŏn)
China Lan Fangwei
籃芳威
  Poetry by men and women of Chosŏn, organized by poem type 25
1600

Chaoxian shixuan
朝鮮詩選
(Selected Poems of Chosŏn)

Chang'an, China Wu Mingji
吳明濟

Wu Mingji, anthology's preface; Hŏ Kyun 許筠, postscript to Nansŏrhŏn's poems

Poetry by men and women of Chosŏn, organized by poem type 58
ca. 1608 Nansŏrhŏn Jip
雪蘭軒集
(Collected Works of Nansŏrhŏn)
Chunchong Province,
Chosŏn
Hŏ Kyun
許筠
Zhu Zhifan 朱之蕃, introduction; Liang Youyu
梁有(上禾+下亏), foreward; Hŏ Kyun 許筠, postscript
210 poems, 1 fu, and 2 essays by Hŏ Nansŏrhŏn 210
1612 Jusha yuanchang in Genshi
亙史的聚沙元倡
China Pan Zhiheng
潘之恆
  168 poems and 1 essay by Hŏ Nansŏrhŏn 168
1620 Gujin mingyuan huishi
古今名媛彙詩
China Zheng Wenang
鄭文昂
  Poems by 6 Korean women 41
after 1626 Mingyuan shigui
名媛詩歸
China Zhong Xing
鍾惺
Zhong Xing Poems by gentry women, courtesans, Daoist nuns, painters, women officials, and 7 Korean women; biographical notes & commentaries; organized by poet 68
1628 Gujin nushi ji 古今女史集: Gujin nushi qianji 古今女史前集, Gujin nushi shiji 古今女史詩集 China Zhao Shijie
趙世杰
Zhao Shijie, biography;
Zhu Yanglun
朱鍚綸, preface
Writings and poetry by Korean women; includes 1 chapter of biographies 40
1632 Nansŏrhŏn Jip
雪蘭軒集
(Collected Works of Nansŏrhŏn)
Chosŏn Hŏ Kyun
許筠
Zhu Zhifan 朱之蕃, preface; Liang Youyu
梁有(上禾+下亏), foreward; Hŏ Kyun 許筠, postscript
Reprint of 1608 version of Nansŏrhŏn Jip; 210 poems, 1 fu, and 2 essays by Hŏ Nansŏrhŏn 210
1649-1652 Liechao shiji
列朝詩集
(Collected Poems of the Dynasties)
China Qian Qianyi
錢謙益 and
Liu Shi 柳是
Qian Qianyi and Liu Shi, preface, annotations, and biography Works by courtesans and gentry women; works by 40 Korean poets 19
1664-1667 Mingyuan shiwei chubian
名媛詩緯初編
China Wang Duanshu
王端淑
Qian Qianyi, prefaces; Wang Duanshu and Tang Hairuo 湯海若, biographies and commentaries

42 juan of 1,000 women poets; Chapter 28 for foreigners includes 5 Korean women poets and one female mistaken for a Korean

7
1673 Cuilou ji
翠樓集
China Liu Yunfen
劉雲份
Zong Yuanding, foreword

700 poems by 200 women; includes a section, zuli, that gives regional origins of poets

25
1692

Nansorjip
雪蘭集

Chosŏn unknown Zhu Zhifan 朱之蕃, preface; Liang Youyu
梁有(上禾+下亏), foreward; Hŏ Kyun 許筠, postscript
210 poems, 1 fu, 2 essays by Hŏ Nansŏrhŏn 210
1705 Mingshi zong
明詩綜
China

Zhu Yizun
朱彝尊

Zhu Yizun, preface;
also uses Zhong Xing's and Liu Shi's prefaces
More than 90 Korean poets, biographies 5
1831 Guochao guixiu zhengshi ji
國朝閨秀正始集
China Yun Zhu
惲珠
Yun Zhu, biography 20 chapters, 3 appendices 7
Early Qing Yishi jiyu
譯史紀餘
China Lu Ciyun
陸次雲
Biography very similar to that in Mingyuan shigui
名媛詩歸
Selected from Liechao shiji
列朝詩集 with reference to Chosŏn Sisŏn 朝鮮詩選; includes poems by 6 Korean women
9

 back to top
   

logo

2007 Columbia University