| Famous Philo | Class year | How he/she brought glory to the society |
| Edmund Pendleton | 1805 | US Congressman |
|---|---|---|
| Peter Dumont Vroom | 1808 | New Jersey governor |
| Jackson Kemper | 1809 | Theologian |
| Benjamin Onderdonk | 1809 | New York bishop |
| William Backhouse Astor | 1811 | Financier |
| Charles Ferris | 1811 | Congressman |
| Stephen Watts Kearny | 1812 | Maj. Gen. |
| Charles Anthon | 1815 | Classical scholar |
| William Beach Lawrence | 1818 | Acting Rhode Island Governor |
| James Lenox | 1818 | Bibliophile |
| John Lloyd Stephens | 1822 | Explorer |