Myths about poverty lines
Abstract: By the sheer loudness of their protests, NGOs, journalists and intellectuals have bamboozled the prime minister into withdrawing the latest Planning Commission report. The report had shown accelerated poverty reduction, a perfectly plausible outcome in view of accelerated growth since 2003-04. But the critics are not happy that India is succeeding in combating destitution. They therefore tirelessly invent myths to muddy the discourse. If we are to avoid costly policy mistakes, we must expose these myths for what they are.
The first myth is that the Planning Commission plays fast and loose with poverty lines. This myth, endlessly repeated in the media, is an insult to the country’s finest tradition of letting professionalism rule without any political interference whatsoever in setting the poverty lines. According to Professor T N Srinivasan, arguably the world’s top living expert on poverty, the history of poverty lines in India goes as far back as 1876. That year, Dadabhai Naoroji provided the first set of poverty lines for various regions of India in a paper entitled ‘Poverty of India’.